An Act 250 permit, the state’s land use and development approval, was issued last week for an Interstate 89 Exit 16 and Route 7 overhaul in Colchester, a signalized interchange known as the “diverging diamond.”
The permit authorizes the Vermont Agency of Transportation to widen the roadways, improve banking and minimize conflicting crossing traffic movements at the intersection. Pedestrian walkways are also set for improvement, the permit says.
The project will also add turning lanes at Lower Maintain View Drive, Mountain View Drive, Hercules Drive and Rathe Road.
The project is one of the traffic mitigation solutions offered in the permit approving warehouse expansion and gas pump installation at nearby Costco. Colchester planning and zoning director Sarah Hadd confirmed her department was set to issue a building permit for the gas pump project in the coming days.
Jon Anderson, a lawyer representing Maplefields’ gas station mogul Skip Vallee, said he and his client are studying the Exit 16 decision closely. Vallee, who owns the Maplefields on Route 7 near Costco, is currently appealing the project’s stormwater permit.
Vallee has engaged in lengthy litigation with the corporation after it presented plans to add gas pumps to the store in 2007.
In August, the Vermont Supreme Court ruled Costco could proceed with its expansions after the specific improvements were made to Lower and Upper Mountain View drives.
Mark Hall, an attorney for Costco, said the diverging diamond portion of the Exit 16 project would help his clients mitigate traffic, but noted it was not an integral step. The court decision allows the corporation to move forward before the Exit 16 changes are made.
Anderson said his client’s frequent appeals are not about stalling competition and instead focus on leveling “the playing field.”
“If you comply with the law, you get your permits,” Anderson said. “Other people have read [into] it, but I think we’ve taken the position that the Exit 16 project can be improved.”
But as the Costco project broaches the 10-year mark, Hadd said the Exit 16 overhaul has already stretched even longer.
“This is something we were studying well before Costco,” she said.
The town has held off on badly needed pedestrian improvements in the area, Hadd explained, knowing an extensive construction project like the diverging diamond would require them to rip out any newly laid sidewalks.
The opinion issued by the Supreme Court called the Exit 16 project’s timeline “uncertain” and estimated construction could “run to 10 years or more.”
In the meantime, town manager Dawn Francis said drivers face lengthy wait times and dangerous traffic patterns at the intersection while pedestrians “take their life in their hands” trying to walk from Winooski to the Shaw’s supermarket.
“It’s not only a vehicular safety issue,” Francis said. “It’s a pedestrian issue.”
Meanwhile, the Costco appeals have yet to cease.
Just last Thursday, Francis received a notice of appeal from Vallee challenging an Act 250 jurisdictional opinion made by district coordinator Peter Keibel.
Keibel’s opinion determined Costco did not need to seek an amendment to its Act 250 permit to modify its stormwater system, Anderson said.
“Those changes were approved by the Environmental Court,” the appeal states, “but were never considered or presented to the District 4 Environmental Commission.”
Keibel did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Hadd said the latest appeal will not stall the town’s issuance of a building permit for the gas pumps, but Francis says it’s symptomatic of a larger problem with the Act 250 process.
“It’s unfortunate that someone is using a permitting process to appeal at every level,” she said. “That has impacts on businesses wanting to locate here in Vermont.”
Hadd believes the problems lie in the Act 250 design, something she called a “set of rules operating without a plan.” Only a small percentage of permits are appealed, she said, but those that are litigated face serious delays.
“It can create a level of frustration within that community when very few people can stymie that process,” Hadd said.
She suggested concerned parties air their grievances during the planning process, rather than working to appeal decisions after the fact. That approach would save resources on both ends, she added.
At a legislative breakfast early last week, Francis suggested lawmakers work to consolidate the permits. Under Act 250, applicants are asked to file for upward of 27 permits before obtaining approval, she said.
Costco has stayed in for the long haul, however, and Francis said she hopes the lengthy litigation history is nearing a close.
Chris Stafford, Costco’s warehouse manager, said he still expects the pumps to make their arrival in springtime – selling Grade A gasoline on land across from the Spare Time bowling alley.
Stafford’s conservative estimates place Costco’s future gas prices 15 cents lower per gallon than the town average.
He’s spent 21 years at seven different Costco locations, taking over the Vermont branch just seven months ago. Colchester is the only store he’s worked at without gas pumps.
He expects drivers will go out of their way to get gas at Costco, just as his customers did in other states.
“Competition is good,” Stafford said. “The guy up the hill is going to want to be better. The consumer wins.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here