COLCHESTER — Although universal free school meals statewide has been an important equity win in providing for the youth of Vermont, Colchester School District joins others in saying state funding for this measure has not been enough for the district to break even.
This and more came out of a food services report made to the school board at its meeting last Tuesday, presented by district nutrition and food services director Steve Davis.
The district is up by about 9% in September and October for meals served, as compared to the fall months of last school year, for both breakfast and lunch. Davis believes this has been accomplished through a focus on honing the menu, as well as, unsurprisingly, universal meals.
“A really positive step in the right direction right now: universal meals has made a huge impact for Colchester being able to feed all of our students and not have to worry about food insecurities and things like that,” he said.
Finance-wise, however, things are not looking as positive.
Although CSD food services had hoped to make a bit of money or at least break even, it lost about $21,000 and revenue is down from last year — partially because the school is no longer receiving infusions of public pandemic funding, and partially because expenses are on the rise.
Despite the widely-acknowledged massive win of universal meal provisions through Act 64, Colchester is not alone in struggling with having enough funds to sustain its school district’s universal meal coverage without monetary losses.
“You see the news every day, you see how food prices are going up,” Davis said. “Anywhere from 3% to 15% on certain items, depending on how we can procure them and get them so again — that's a real challenge, when we're getting $2.26 from the government for a breakfast, and $4.41 for a lunch.”
The department has also been struggling to get enough chocolate milk cartons to meet the children’s demand in light of a milk shortage.
Additionally, the school has the constrictions of having to abide by the federal meal requirements as well as appealing to students appetites and ensuring meals are healthy and variable.
“You really have to be inventive to try and come up with meals that the kids like and will eat, because we don't want to see them go in the garbage,” he said.
Davis also mentioned labor costs and the fact that in the last several years they’ve replaced a substantial amount of failing equipment, though the need for oven upgrades in certain school buildings, as well kitchen costs in all facilities, continues.
Ovens cost about $15,000 a piece, and several are “hanging on by a thread,” he said. The department recently replaced a dishwasher at Colchester Middle School which was $42,000, but several dishwashers at the younger schools are also on their last legs.
One salad bar is getting to be quite old and a few stand up milk coolers are also wearing down.
“One of the reasons why we can't break even or make money is really with all these costs, it's a real challenge to get a meal when you factor everything in to come in under those hills and mountains,” Davis said.
The school district may need to solicit funds from the voter budget going forward to compensate in light of this, he said — which is common in Vermont, said George Trieb, CSD business and operations manager — though it hasn’t commonly been done in Colchester.
The school will likely need $90,000 more than the typical voter-approved education spending budget to offset food costs that the state’s universal school meal funding doesn’t cover.
Trieb said the district is projecting a $27,000 loss for this fiscal year in the end from dining, with $50,000 or so on top of that figure for the expected cost of repairing and replacing aging equipment.
“I don't know how much more revenue we can bring in on meals right now,” Davis said. “We're serving over 70% of the students, which is a high percentage. So that's where we get into a tough spot because it's not like a restaurant where you raise your prices and do a lot of things to bring in more revenue. We will do things to increase participation, but we're at a really high end.”
His dream, he said, would be to get 100% of the student body to eat school lunch.
Despite the financial challenges, universal school meal provisions are undeniably a win, he said.
There were always students who didn’t quite qualify for free or reduced meals whose families still couldn’t really afford good meals for their kids, or students with parents that lost a job in the middle of the school year after the deadline to apply for free or reduced meals, or families too prideful to take advantage of meal discounts they qualified for.
“There's no stigma at all with a school lunch now because everybody's eating a school lunch,” Davis said. “The cafeteria is more vibrant, more kids are eating. Just everybody knows to go get lunch. It's no big deal. When people were paying it was a big deal.”
“It's something that I dreamed about for the 21 years that I was here,” he added. “I hope and pray that we never have to go back to the old way.”
The state will continue to fund universal school meals for at least two or three more years, but he hopes the state will do so indefinitely until down the line the federal government considers making it a federal law and funding it for schools across America.
“I just can't imagine going back to charging some of the students for meals,” Davis said. “I want to put something on the plate that students will eat so they don't go home hungry.”
Beyond the universal meals, other issues within the department have arisen in recent years.
“Staffing has been a real challenge,” Davis said. “I think right now I'm only one person short. We don't have very many subs — my staff steps up and helps with that a lot. We're doing great and it's better this year that it has been in past years. But it's a real challenge finding quality staffing.”
Davis has had an ad for some time now and has had one person apply in the last two weeks.
Still, the staff he does have never taken a day off during the COVID-19 pandemic and he feels lucky to be backed by their work ethic, and the fact that his department doesn’t experience a lot of turnover generally.
Food services is one person short out of 28 total staff, or 29 counting the Director Davis himself.
Also a challenge coming up in April, is that the schools’ food services department will undergo its administrative review. It’s normally done every three years, and Colchester is, in a sense, overdue, as it's been five years since its food services department has been reviewed.
“It's a huge administrative demand for both food service, central office,” Davis said.
The review involves going through what the department is doing for all of its meal applications and claims, ensuring that menus and accounting are following proper guidelines, doing food safety checks, reviewing procurement processes and more.
Meals the school is serving these days include pancakes with local Vermont maple syrup, turkey sausage and sweet potato Tater Tots, and hot honey cheddar chicken croissants made with raisins and whole grain alongside orange glazed carrots, and he included photos of each example in his slideshow.
A friend of Davis’ encouraged him to concentrate on meals of the world, so additionally they’ve incorporated a weekly Tuesday world meals rotation to try to reach students from different diverse backgrounds in the district and introduce the entire student body to other cultures.
Davis showed the school board imagery of chicken pita with tzatziki sauce and melon mint salad as well as a Moroccan stew — the chicken pizza went over great; the stew wasn’t as popular.
“Some of them the kids go crazy for, some of them they don't,” Davis said. “We talk to them after the meals, we find out what they like, what they don't like [...] But the kids are loving it and we do it every Tuesday.”
Davis said he hopes to continue to upgrade the menu to be even more robust and diverse, and to include more scratch cooking and less processed foods once the department is fully staffed.
They’ve also had a macaroni and cheese bar with a choice of toppings that they could put on top of the macaroni and cheese such as barbecue pulled pork, barbecue chicken or buffalo chicken. They’ve also served yogurt with cherries, chicken parm sandwiches with Caesar salad made with kale, chicken and veggies over rice, the “loaded Laker dog” which is chili cheese dog with a Dorito crumble — and much more.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here