Department of Environmental Conservation presents on watershed pollutant pilot program slated to launch in Colchester

Posted

COLCHESTER — The Vermont Department of Environmental Conservation led a public meeting Wednesday morning to discuss the chloride pollution at Sunnyside Brook. 

The presentation, held at Colchester’s Main Street Meeting House, demonstrated to folks the state of chloride pollution in Sunnyside Brook and outlined the “Total Maximum Daily Load” plan for the brook moving forward. The plan will establish an ideal limit on chloride pollution, mainly from wintertime road salt, not to be surpassed for the sake of the health of waterway wildlife. 

This will be the first TMDL in the state of Vermont, and among the first in the country, to be set specifically in relation to chloride as a pollutant, which is toxic to aquatic life in excess. 

The intent in this instance is to use the program being piloted at Sunnyside Brook, which runs through Sunny Hollow Natural Area, as a blueprint for future chloride-specific TMDLs in other chloride-impaired waters statewide. 

Most of the waterways with excessively high chloride pollution levels known to the state are in the greater Burlington area and eventually run off into Lake Champlain. This is partially due to the region’s relatively developed, urban features with lots of impervious surfaces like parking lots and roadways requiring road salt near streams, but also in part due to more research being conducted in watersheds in this region, on chloride and other contaminants. 

While the TMDL does serve to establish ideal limits on contaminants in the water, it will not on its own establish any legally binding regulations, management or enforcement strategies. 

The Clean Water Act obligates states to create TMDLs for impaired waters, setting a scientifically-backed numerical target limit for how saturated a body of water can be with any given contaminant without substantially harming the ecosystems it carries, with TMDLs to be approved by the Environmental Protection Agency. 

A small handful of people sat to watch the informational meeting in person Wednesday, with about a dozen tuning into the meeting online. 

DEC TMDL coordinator Tim Clear led the bulk of the presentation, with assistance in presenting a science and hydrology segment from his colleague, watershed management hydrologist Blaine Hastings, who also works for the DEC. 

“Chloride is kind of unique,” Clear said in his presentation. “It is conservative. Essentially, it doesn't react in soils. So it really can't be sequestered once it's out there in the watershed. It’s not taken up by biota, it can’t be harvested by plants for instance. And it's water-soluble and therefore it can be filtered.” 

Due to the reasons aforementioned, source reduction is the most practical management strategy. But unfortunately for the health of Vermont’s flora and fauna, chloride is also the most cost-effective winter safety tool to minimize slipping hazards on non-absorbent surfaces for ice and snow, so a balance must be struck between water quality and winter safety interests. 

“So it's a tricky pollutant to deal with,” Clear said. 

For all the above reasons, traditional stormwater treatment strategies tend not to treat chloride. 

Hastings did the monitoring and technical work to settle on the Sunnyside TMDL as it stands. 

The main goal of the data collection phase was to characterize the water quality conditions and develop a long-term daily streamflow dataset to capture the chloride pollution in continuous and acute water quality conditions with respect to chloride, as well as to derive what's called the filtration curve and establish a Target Maximum Daily Load from that, Hastings said. 

In five out of the eight years in which the state has conducted biomonitoring research on chloride levels in Sunnyside Hollow, it did not meet established standards for ecologically healthy chloride levels. Chloride concentrations from December 2019 to November 2020 were above the acute standard 23% of the time and above the chronic standard 100% of the time. 

A few of the only previously existing chloride TMDLs in the U.S. are in New Hampshire, Minnesota and Virginia. 

“This is our first foray into developing or satisfying the TMDL requirements for chloride here in Vermont,” Hastings said. 

The annual net chloride TMDL target load for Sunnyside Brook is slated to be set at 122.3 tons.  

The watershed drains the area around Costco, Shaws, several hotels, Camp Johnson, I-89, Vermont Route 7, some municipal roads, the Sunny Hollow Natural Area and other surrounding private properties.

Potential management strategies include allotting certain entities higher-priority, for example, allocating roads with a larger allotments of road salt per year, or by tracking road salt application among a number of large entities, or incentivizing a reduction of road salt application through future legislation based on a New Hampshire model in which certified salt applicators using appropriate amounts of salt are eligible to qualify for limited liability for slip-and-fall litigation. 

However, another factor playing into the situation as it stands at Sunnyside Brook and in many other watersheds, is that about three quarters of the paved or otherwise non-porous surfaces that run off into the water are privately owned lots and sidewalks or are otherwise fragmented across assorted private properties, which poses challenging implications for future regulation. 

“It's a tricky management scenario,” Clear said. “That's a lot of people, and without a permit to control that, I don't have any obvious management solutions right now.” 

Administrative next-steps at the DEC level are to take comments through the public comment period, which closes March 27, develop a response to those comments, and finalize the TMDL — and then, to find, verify and address other chloride-impacted watershed TMDLs in the future. 

More information can be found on the DEC website and comments may be submitted in writing to Tim.Clear@vermont.gov.

#csnltop, #chloride tmdl

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here