Editor's note: This story was updated Sept. 30 at 9:10 a.m. to correct the goal set by the selectboard for the maximum amount the budget should be increased — the figure, 5.7%, was and is correct. However, a previous version of this story stated that number was that maximum desired increase in tax rate, rather than budget.
COLCHESTER — Town administration requested guidance from the selectboard Tuesday night about budgeting priorities as management works to build a municipal services budget for fiscal year 2026.
To cut service offerings or to minimize inevitable tax increases? That is the question.
Renae Marshall, assistant town manager, discussed town planning for the coming fiscal year with respect to labor force, inflation, costs of labor and production, resource needs, external pressures and constraints, and approach and process, requesting feedback and recommendations from the selectboard at the end of her presentation to the board.
Ultimately, the selectboard advised prioritizing maintaining the past three-year-average budget increase of no more than 5.7%, with the intent to review any services that must fall out of the budget as a result.
To read more about the specific pressures plaguing Vermont as a whole — largely relating to stagnant populations as a result of inadequate housing stock, in turn, decreasing the availability of other kinds of opportunity in the state — click here.
“It’s going to be tough,” said selectboard chair Pam Loranger. “I’m not so sure we’re going to make the targets we’ve had in the past to create a budget that’s going to work for the voters this year. In terms of services, we’re just going to have to be efficient and effective.”
“Those are important words madam chairman,” Town Manager Aaron Frank replied.
So — what factors are at play in contributing to the squeeze? Let’s break it down.
As included in the selectboard memo on this coming year’s budget planning, the labor force participation rate, or the percentage of the Vermont population that is either working or actively looking for work, decreased from 66.7% in January 2019 to 65.1% in January 2024, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
In February of 2024, Vermont had 17,000 job openings or 5.2%, when comparing job openings as a percent of employment, compared to 4.5% in February of 2020. As of July 2024, there are only 0.5 people per open job according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Chittenden County unemployment pre-COVID-19, measured in July 2019, was 1.6% or 1,632, and is, as of July 2024, now 1.9% or 1,992, constituting 360 more people unemployed or seeking employment.
This statewide trend affects Colchester’s local economy and increases the costs of goods, services and labor, all of which are necessary to provide municipal services. There is a scarcity of employees for both town positions and contracted work, from seasonal staff to year-round, spanning all town services.
Employment participation, or labor force, is currently far more impactful than the unemployment rate, in considering how many people are available to participate in the economy as workers.
Colchester is not planning for increased levels of service, but per the memo, it does need to budget for known cost increases.
Inflation has fluctuated since its peak in June of 2022. Inflation increased by 3.6% from July 2023 to July 2024. Historically, rates have ranged from -0.4% to 3.8% annually, since 2000.
The rate of inflation the town experienced over the past several years led to significant increases in expenses, including service contracts, supplies, vehicles, equipment and labor.
Employment costs for the Northeast, including the private sector, rose by 4.1% from June 2023 to June 2024. The Producer Price Index, which reflects costs of the production of goods and services provided to end consumers, increased 3.3% from August 2023 to August 2024.
There are currently seven vacant municipal positions, including five police officers, one IT director, and one public works administrator and engineering position.
Inflation rates, employment costs and producer prices, have a substantial impact on the town’s ability to provide services and capital projects.
The selectboard has been notified at a previous meeting of possible future resource needs to maintain the current levels of town services over the next five years. Not all of these issues would come to fruition in a single year and likely not all over the course of the five-year term.
As in the past, the town will continue to explore ways to offset some increased expenses with reduced costs in other areas.
Colchester needs an additional half-time employee to complete the reappraisal. This person would be hired this winter and on on staff through December 2026.
The selectboard has supported moving to a rolling reappraisal in the future so that the town can keep up with revaluation primarily in-house, instead of hiring a large out-of-state firm every decade. This would require the half-time position to remain on staff following the reappraisal.
The town is also not staffed sufficiently to keep up with facility maintenance and the capital projects it has to implement, with available grants and voter-approved Local Option Tax funding. The town has created, and is advertising, a Public Works Engineer II position to assist with this.
This year, the position will be funded by the Colchester Recreation Center capital authorization. In the future, it would be partially funded with proceeds from solar sales and property taxes.
The town has also changed the pay structure for volunteer firefighters from a stipend system to a paid-on-call system. This reflects a change in federal law related to fire protective equipment as well as providing an additional incentive for volunteers which is used in most neighboring communities with volunteer or partially-volunteer run departments.
This will increase Colchester’s volunteer payroll. But given the call volume of actual fires, staff say this is a far more cost-effective manner to resource fire protection than a large full-time department.
The town also needs to replace the bridge on Creek Farm Road. It has a temporary bridge on loan from the state and a grant for $200,000 to replace the bridge, but needs to come up with a funding plan for the remaining $500,000.
With fewer people working or looking for work in Vermont than pre-COVID-19, the town is finding more competition between public and private sector employers to fill positions which also impacts the resources needed to maintain the current level of services.
Tax Exempt Property
More social, human services and housing are being offered by nonprofit and governmental organizations. These services help individuals and families in need, especially when the cost of living is going up and housing is scarce.
Most of these organizations and their properties, including housing properties owned by non-profits, are tax-exempt or partially tax-exempt. In 2024, the value of completely tax-exempt property in Colchester is $185,948,200, or 8.1% of the total value of all property in Colchester.
Colchester has the third most tax-exempt property in Chittenden County, following Burlington and Jericho. Jericho hosts the Camp Ethan Allen Training Site, and Burlington non-profits provide the city with “support payments” amounting to 17 times more than those provided to Colchester as a proportional share of its budgets.
When tax-exempt organizations purchase or develop a property, taxes that are or would be paid on that property are shifted to other non-exempt taxpayers—both residential and commercial.
Homeownership and Income
Of Chittenden County communities represented in the U.S. Census, Colchester also has one of the highest homeownership rates among the lower-income communities, at a rate of 71%.
Other than St. George, Colchester has the highest percentage of homeownership among the six Chittenden County communities with the lowest median income.
The homeownership rate in Colchester is much higher than the rates in Burlington and Winooski, which are the only two communities with higher percentages of low-income households. The homeownership percentage in Colchester is more comparable to communities that are generally more affluent, including Essex, Shelburne and Hinesburg.
Because the municipal services budget is, by state statute, funded primarily by local property taxes, it is important to remember that a lot of the community depends on maintaining a sustainable tax rate. Town administration say this severely tempers their proposals to increase municipal services. It isn’t just the willingness to pay, but importantly, the ability to pay.
Designated Capital Funding
This approach is sound, and should continue, but restricts options, according to town management. Colchester has multiple voter-approved capital funding plans.
These are positive in that they provide ongoing dedicated funding to maintain, but not expand or improve, roads, bridges and paths; buildings, vehicles and equipment; parks; telecommunications, computers and radio systems; and specialized public safety equipment.
Funding these capital needs with a “pay-as-we-go” system allows the town to avoid the costs of interest through borrowing; reduce budget spikes; eliminate a “use-it-or-lose-it” approach to budgeting; and importantly, mandates that funding be spent on capital alone.
Similarly, the local option tax is designed in Colchester’s voter-approved charter, for voter-approved capital only.
The fiscal year 2025 capital budget and five year capital plan is here.
Town management supports these programs to properly maintain its investments. During challenging times, there is no ability to shift priorities from capital to operating expenses; the capital must be funded separate from operating.
Services
Considering community needs and fiscal unknowns, town management is not recommending changes in the level of services beyond those listed above in the subsection of this article entitled “resource needs.”
Administrators will continue their ongoing efforts to evaluate and implement changes over the course of the current and next fiscal year to respond to changing needs, opportunities and fiscal realities.
For reference, the municipal services budget increase last year was 6.0% and averaged 5.7% over the last three years.
Revenues
Understanding the fiscal situation of the community, town management has promised to work hard on both the expense and revenue side of the budget’s development to keep the tax rate as affordable as possible, without a reduction in services.
Most growth in the grand list is expected to be residential. For reference, the tax rate increase last year was 4.7% and the average tax rate increase over the last three years was 4.5%.
Process
The town manager’s office will work with department heads and externally-funded organizations to understand needs for the upcoming fiscal year, then propose a budget to the selectboard considering relative priorities — given overall community needs and goals, the community’s ability to fund these needs, and the selectboard’s input.
Drafting of department budgets is to be developed and finalized by Oct. 23, and from then through Nov. 19, town management will work with department heads to review, revise and summarize the budget. The initial budget will be provided to the selectboard Nov. 22.
The draft budget will be finalized with town management and the selectboard Dec. 3, with the selectboard to approve it on Jan. 14, 2025 if ready, and a presentation on the capital plans and ballot items to accompany the warning of a public hearing on these topics to follow the same day.
With other events leading up to it in February, Town Meeting Day will be held for voting March 4.
With the consumer price, employment cost and producer price indexes at 3.6%, 4.1% and 3.3%, respectively, reflecting higher costs for goods, services and employment, the town would need to reduce services to bring in a pre-COVID-19 tax rate.
Town staff say they respect the community and selectboard’s goal of financial sustainability, and town management intends to do its best to bring in a budget and tax rate considering affordability, but without reducing the current level of services.
However, upon hearing input from the selectboard, it was established at the meeting’s end — with the recommendation originating from Tom Mulcahy — that the town develop a budget in line with a budget increase of no more than the three-year-average of 5.7%, excluding the half-time assessor position.
If services must fall out of the budget to keep the increase as low as that, the selectboard will review and evaluate the cost and value of each service slated to be cut once the draft comes back in for selectboard review.
Loranger asked town management what healthcare costs are shaking out to look like, and Marshall informed Loranger it’s to be determined, with town management still actively working through negotiations.
“Let’s sharpen our pencils,” Frank said, in response to the guidance — prompting a nervous, though determined, chuckle from the board.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here