COLCHESTER — Residents showed up at the latest Colchester selectboard meeting to share their concerns about the recent reappraisal’s impact on their taxes.
During the Tuesday, Aug. 11 meeting, many residents said their taxes had been raised too high following the reappraisal of their property value earlier this year. Many said they felt misled by previous communication from the town that there would be a more modest increase.
“This kind of feels like a bait and switch in some regards,” resident Andy Edwards said. “I had [a property assessor] come to my house… and his words were, ‘If anything, it's going to be a modest increase…’ So I know there were a lot of things that changed this deal with the state and all, but words matter.”
Town taxes increased by 10.7% while taxes for the State of Vermont’s education fund increased by 21.3% for a property assessed at $600,000. In total, 85% of the year-over-year increase came from the State of Vermont’s education fund, according to information provided by the town.
As mandated by state law, reappraisals are conducted every few years in Vermont to ensure taxpayers are paying their fair share based on the current market value of their property. Property values increase alongside inflation.
Since Colchester’s last reappraisal, commercial property values increased 67% compared to 102% for residential properties, which is largely attributed to the shift to work from home during the COVID-19 pandemic. As more people worked remotely, commercial properties became less valuable.
Resident Alice Avery said the town should’ve let residential taxpayers know their taxes are making up for a decrease in value from commercial properties.
“We're all now paying as residents for the commercial decrease, and that was never communicated,” she said. “When we get our tax bills, and we're getting a 20% increase, that is really a shock to us and should have been communicated.”
As a result of changes in the commercial market, the municipal portion of taxes for residential payers also increased by more than what had been voted on during Town Meeting Day in March, Avery said. But the town is not collecting more taxes as a result.
Town Manager Aaron Frank said the town communicated many of these possibilities in advance, but that the impact of COVID-19 on commercial property values was hard to predict.
Additionally, the legislature capped the Common Level of Appraisal adjustment at 100%, rather than the final CLA of 106.05% in Colchester. This had the impact of creating an extra tax on the 40 towns undergoing reappraisals this year, including Colchester.
“The state education fund is collecting more revenue on these 40towns, and as a result, it costs the residents, the taxpayers, more on their state education tax,” Deputy Town Manager Renae Marshall said.
Resident Matt Andrews expressed concern about the complexity of the system and the lack of transparency about how it works.
“It's just concerning that we all say we don't have any control,” he said. “Who does? That's what I really want to know: who do we get in front of to figure out how it works? You folks all have a much larger voice than any individual taxpayer.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here