Colchester selectboard skeptical about joining CUD but it may be the only option for the town to see any state money for broadband

Posted

After months of speaking with state officials, boards and Communications Union Districts, the Town of Colchester now sees one option to access state money that would be used to reach the around 200 addresses in town that remain unserved or underserved: joining a CUD.

Previously, the town had been hesitant of this option, saying there was no overwhelming justification for joining a CUD.

But at the June 28 selectboard meeting, part-time project manager Meredith Dolan and Town Manager Aaron Frank said they see no other options to access state money.

This solution however, leaves no one particularly satisfied, including Dolan and Frank, because connecting Colchester’s underserved addresses to high speed internet is less of a priority for the state, they said.

The way the Vermont Community Broadband Board doles out grants gives less to towns like Colchester, who would largely benefit from something like a Line Extension Program as opposed to building a new network.

In May of last year, the Town of Colchester proposed a legislative change to Act 71, the bill providing the framework for the state’s broadband plan, to institute a cable line extension program, according to a June 23 memo from the town.

The change however received little support from the VCBB.

Previously, the state had such a program and some Colchester residents who were able to receive some of that money now have high speed internet. Now, no such program exists.

The memo notes however, that the past 10 months of work done by Dolan and the town offices has raised awareness about this issue at the state level.

The most recent discussions that have occurred are centered around how Colchester and towns like it in Chittenden County can work within the Act 71 framework.

This stil leaves Colchester in an odd position, fitting a square peg into a round hole. Given the equation the VCBB uses to dole out money, the amount of money Colchester could receive joining or creating a CUD is minimal compared to the money needed to reach full coverage.

At the meeting, Dolan said that most of the signs for Colchester are now pointing to the creation of a Communications Union District.

“We had been hoping that we wouldn’t have to create one in Chittenden County because it is a new form of government which would require oversight and administration and just ongoing effort,” Dolan said. “And there really are few people percentage wise that don't have access to some level of relatively good internet Chittenden County and we thought if we can solve the problem without creating this new layer of government, that that probably would be more efficient.”

Dolan said that it seems like if Colchester is to receive any of the money coming from the state for broadband, the town would need to be a part of a CUD.

“We would hate to see the funding that's available get spent and us to not have benefited from it if we can do it in a way that works for us,” she said.

How broadband is funded

The way the VCBB decides how much money a town receives for broadband expansion is a formula, primarily relying on the number of uncabled miles that exist in the town. For Colchester that number is small.

By that calculation, the most Colchester could receive is around $460,000. The money needed to reach all 200 addresses in Colchester is at least around $7 million.

Dolan said that although that is a very small amount of money, they would rather get it than lose it.

In addition, the VCBB’s goal is to fund a maximum of 60% of the projects the CUDs take on. The hope is that the rest could be covered by American Rescue Plane Act money or by providers themselves providing capital.

Using ARPA money however is not an option for Colchester given the amount of apportionment already going to the Malletts Bay Sewer Project.

The town has been in conversation with communities in northern Chittenden County like Essex, Westford and South Burlington about creating a CUD.

Creating a CUD

The process to create the CUD requires a public vote by at least two communities, and that vote could be held during this November’s general election. Dolan said some of the other communities mentioned are thinking about this.

In terms of liability to the town and the taxpayers as a result of a CUD, Dolan said she’s been assured that there is very little. The point of the CUD is to protect towns from the concerns of things like incurring debt.

She said a town can still leave a CUD even after debt is incurred.

Frank said he wants to do good with what the town has access to, but was clear that there can be no promises in terms of bringing full high-speed coverage to Colchester’s unserved or underserved.

His memo states a challenge: the town needs to join a CUD to access funding, but can’t make any assurances to the selectboard or the voters about outcomes if they vote to join a CUD.

"We don't feel this is something we can offer to the voters and say, 'Hey, we're going to deliver something to you,'" Frank said. "We're not even sure we can...We might be able to cover one more neighborhood, that's great. But it's hard to get excited about this.”

Dolan said the VCBB thinks now is the time for a Chittenden County CUD. Some selectboard members disagreed.

Board members weigh in

Colchester selectboard member Tom Mulcahy took opposition to Act 71’s focus on cable technology more generally, saying the future of broadband is not going to come from cable.

Mulcahy said the only way to do it is to have an “umbrella that will cover the entire town,” meaning a way to access the internet that doesn’t rely on cable infrastructure.

“Each year you are going to have new people building new homes at the end of something that's not going to have the internet, it's going to continue on forever, this small percentage will always be there,” Mulcahy said.

Dolan said at her last appearance at a selectboard meeting, they discussed satellite internet. Although some people have found success with it, there are definitely some aspects that don’t work well for Colchester, she said.

Currently, satellite internet remains difficult for residents in areas where there are trees as they block the satellite’s signal as it travels over.

At least one Colchester resident has tried to receive satellite internet from Starlink, a project started by Elon Musk. The resident was unsuccessful, given the trees that would block the signal.

Dolan said that although that technology may improve, there’s no timeline for when that will happen.

Mulcahy said the millions of dollars needed to get a small amount of Colchester residents broadband coverage is not very cost-effective.

Selectboard member Maureen Dakin said that in reality, no providers are going to want to pick up part of the share to get infrastructure built. With the creation of a CUD, she said, the town needs to consider things like administrative costs and how it's run.

Other CUD’s administrative costs, such as Northwest Fiberworx, come from money doled out by the VCBB.

“I just don't see sending representatives to a board that we have really no say over how it's run, the cost,” Dakin said.

CUD membership does require a representative from each member town to be a part of that district’s board. These members are appointed by the member town’s selectboards.

Frank said the town is currently in this position because there is no interest in the Public Service Department in anything other than implementing Act 71 as written.

“It's all said very politely, but the door is closed,” he said.

Frank said the town has a window now where it can do something.

Selectboard Clerk Charlie Papillo said he’s not optimistic when looking at the discrepancy between the $460,000 the town could receive and the over $7 million the town would need.

Mulcahy asked, “when is the point of no return?”

“I understand the goal is to leave no home behind, at some point, it's cost effective to just stop,” he said.

Frank said that the town is looking at this solution from the same critical perspective the board is.

“We don't want to shut the door on it because it seems like it's the only way, but we appreciate your skepticism,” he said.

Dolan said she and Frank were originally very hopeful that the town could find a solution that wasn’t a CUD. She said that right now, if the town wants to take advantage of that small amount of federal funding, a CUD seems to be the way.

The town has not announced when the topic will be spoken about again.

#csnltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here