Colchester selectboard fails to consider agenda item for letter supporting school district

Posted

Editor's note: This story was updated Oct. 10 at 10:26 a.m. to add context around the final quote included in this story, clarifying the source's point that the school board and selectboard are separate entities. 

COLCHESTER — At its meeting last night, the selectboard failed to consider an item for discussion, marked on the agenda as an opportunity to “send a letter of support for the Colchester school board, district and superintendent.” 

Had the action item passed, it would have authorized selectboard chair Pam Loranger to send a letter of support to the district. The draft letter, though not included in the meeting agenda, has been obtained by the Sun. 

Had it passed, it would have been addressed to school board chair Lindsey Cox — and based on the draft, it would have vocalized selectboard support for the district’s $115 million bond proposal aimed at addressing mounting facility needs. 

The proposal is one of the school board’s biggest current focuses, and the bond itself is slated to appear before voters on the election ballot Nov. 5.

However, the bond initiative has seen some opposition from Colchester residents concerned about the increasing taxpayer burden. 

About the letter and its intent 

Loranger drafted the letter and had Town Manager Aaron Frank add it to the agenda. The draft expresses the selectboard’s appreciation for the work and outcomes of the entire school board and district, and acknowledges both the selectboard and school board — though separate entities — serve the same voters, community and taxpayers. 

Loranger’s draft acknowledged “the school board has worked diligently to address the ever-mounting needs and mandates to support the education of one of our most valuable assets; our youth.” 

“We are very mindful of the challenges presented by crafting budgets that will meet the approval of our residents and their pocketbooks,” Loranger continued in the draft. “We applaud the effort and thoughtful preparation of the $115 million bond request now before Colchester voters.” 

Loranger’s letter draft went on to state the Colchester school board has throughout the last decade presented budgets meeting operating expenses, but which have set aside mounting facility needs. She stated these needs can no longer remain on the sidelines, and this bond is the community’s opportunity to address those long standing issues. 

She then directed voters to the district’s website and public forums, which she stated provide all information necessary for folks to cast an informed vote. 

The bond proposes school building renovations encompassing safety and security, aging infrastructure and space to accommodate current and projected increases in enrollment. 

Local school districts do not determine the formula for education taxes and have little impact on the amount of state education taxes charged to their respective taxpayers, Loranger stated in the draft, due to Vermont’s statewide education funding formula. 

The letter intended to thank CSD on behalf of the board for succeeding with far lower than average costs per student but far higher than average student outcomes, and to support “one of the most important votes we may face in decades,” for the sake of local public education as well as the general future of the Colchester community and its youth. 

When presented to the board officially, none of this came to pass. 

How it all went down at the meeting 

At last night’s meeting, Loranger read the action item. Selectboard clerk Jacki Murphy, per her role as clerk, read the motion, and Loranger asked for a second — followed by a long silence. 

“We need a second if we are going to open it to discussion,” Loranger said at last night’s meeting. “Somebody’s got to second the motion… I guess we don’t have a motion then. Right? Town Manager, if we don’t get a second we can’t take the action?” 

“Correct,” said selectboard member Maureen Dakin. 

Frank nodded. 

The clerk’s official role involves the responsibility of stating initial motions. The chair is not in a position authorized to make a motion or to second one to move it forward to discussion. All five members were present at the meeting. 

Loranger was the only member of the selectboard who responded to the Sun’s inquiry in time for the publication of this story. 

Frank told the Sun in an email today he was unable to add anything. 

“When there is an action item on an agenda, as a matter of parliamentary procedure, it needs a second to be discussed,” he stated in the email, dated Oct. 9. “If there is no second, it doesn’t come up for discussion or a vote.” 

“It doesn’t have a meaning related to the item,” he added. “Just that the selectboard chose not to bring it up for discussion or vote.”  

The logic behind the letter 

If the item passed, Loranger said she would have considered any dialogue among the selectboard at the meeting and incorporated their input into the letter. 

Frank sent the attached rough draft of the letter to the selectboard on Tuesday afternoon. 

“My thought behind the letter was to recognize the Colchester School District for succeeding with far lower than average costs per student but far higher than average student outcomes,” she said, reiterating some of the language in the letter draft. 

“The Colchester School District is conducting a thoughtful public information effort with the Colchester community and the dialogue about the proposal should occur in those forums where the district is able to share, engage and respond directly,” she added. 

Loranger said given the selectboard is elected to address municipal services, it does not often weigh in on symbolic gestures or matters outside of its purview. 

“The fact that the selectboard did not choose to discuss the item is a reminder that the Selectboard is focused on what we were elected to do, to oversee the provision of municipal services,” Loranger said.  

Frank told the Sun he contacted CSD superintendent Amy Minor this morning and let her know there was no action or discussion on the item. 

“We have a great working relationship with the town and the different departments within the town,” Meghan Baule, Colchester School District’s communications director, said. “Parks and Rec and maintenance and the police department, fire department, rescue… We work really well with all of the municipalities of the town."

Baule also pointed out the school board and the selectboard are completely separate municipalities, noting the district does not require permission or approval for any type of initiative from the selectboard — it's the voters and the residents of Colchester who decide.

"In terms of the bond, we focused all of our efforts on informing the public with community presentations, school tours, a dedicated website, video series, residential mailers," she said. "So we are not seeking support from the selectboard. We're just looking to inform the community from the voters of Colchester."

#$115 million bond proposal, #colchester town and colchester school district relations

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here