Colchester sees highest call-to-officer ratio of any department in county, seeks to continue filling vacant positions amidst new era of policing

Posted

COLCHESTER — The Colchester Police Department is currently experiencing the highest volume of calls and incidents handled per officer on staff of any department in Chittenden County. 

Although Burlington has almost triple the call volume to Colchester, Burlington has more officers than Colchester does to handle them, Police Chief Peter Hull told the selectboard Dec. 12. CPD is not alone in operating on a reduced staff, but the department is and has been experiencing a shortage of staff for about four years now. 

Despite that challenge, Chief Hull is optimistic about the department’s new blood and ability to meet the town’s changing needs.

In Colchester, general incidents called in are down slightly this year. Due to reduced staff, the department’s ability to patrol roads is down, but CPD is working to shift more focus back to motor vehicle incidents and road patrolling in order to address substantial traffic safety incidents. 

Larceny has been steadily increasing since 2018, which Hull believes to be fairly consistent throughout Chittenden County. Drug overdoses and unresponsiveness cases have also continued to climb since 2019. However, violent crime has decreased a bit since 2020. 

Calls for incidents involving mental health have grown the most over the years, with the most recent years’ counts being nearly four times higher than that of 2014. The prioritization of the mental health element of police response in recent years may partially account for this uptick, but these types of calls have been substantially climbing statewide. 

When asked by selectboard member Charlie Papillo whether he believed there was any direct correlation between the hotel voucher program and those sort of calls,, Hull said he wasn’t sure — given that the hotels in town once on the voucher program no longer serve as emergency housing in Colchester, and yet the call volume remains high. 

“When we had the hotels, that became a big part of our call volume,” Hull said, still attesting to the notable changes in the hotel voucher era. “It was mental health as well as substances, a lot of people with a lot of different issues in a very small space.” 

Papillo followed up to ask what the state could do to assist municipalities — particularly given the capacity of a limited, stretched staff — in managing these kinds of problems seen statewide. 

“I feel like they tried to create a solution very quickly without any thought to unintended consequences,” Hull said. “We’re loud and vocal in our needs. Sometimes I think they are responsive to that and sometimes I don’t feel like they really are.” 

When the CPD last updated its general orders, it changed its departmental organizational structure to eliminate the deputy chief position, with the next chain of command following the chief to instead be split by two lieutenants — though the deputy position may return at a later date if it is deemed necessary by the town in the future, Hull told the Sun. 

Out of 29 sworn officer positions authorized to the department, there are 22 certified officers filling available positions currently, including a recent hire to graduate from the Vermont Police Academy next month, which will be the third hire of the past year, Hull said. 

This is consistent with the number of filled positions two years ago. At that time, there had been a declining number of qualified applicants for two years prior, or since 2020: the year the COVID-19 pandemic hit as well as the year the Black Lives Matter movement gained momentum. 

Hull said with these shifting tides culturally, expectations of police have been heightened — and in many ways for the better. Conversations about reform and subsequent changes implemented have been largely beneficial, he said. 

However, Hull told the Sun in a subsequent interview he believes the “defund” movement has been an unequivocally negative thing for communities everywhere. 

Additionally — while staffing issues aren’t happening only in law enforcement — he does believe some rhetoric that stemmed from the social movement, which gained traction in 2020, have impacted the reputation of police careers in a way that has made hiring harder since. 

“It's difficult to be a police officer in today's day and age,” Hull told the Sun. “After the number of years I've been doing this I can attest it's always been hard, but I think that it has made it much more challenging to attract candidates.” 

“Whenever a profession is under the microscope, and it's somewhat being attacked, people forget the fundamental reasons of why someone should want to be a police officer — it’s still an honorable profession,” he added. “It's still about serving others in your community. That's what it's supposed to be about. And we have to have people willing to do that.” 

Recruitment efforts are ongoing, with Lieutenant Roger Fischer spearheading and overseeing a committee of officers involved to help. The human resources department, directed by Chad Bouvier, has also been helpful in this process, Hull said. 

Although managing a smaller force has been a challenge, Hull considers incentivization efforts at Colchester’s department, such as pay and benefit packages, to be “pretty competitive.” They are now also offering a sign-on bonus including to new officers who have no prior experience. 

It is a competitive hiring market, with countless other police departments statewide in similar positions and looking to hire. Lots of folks who used to apply to jobs in policing are instead looking to work for federal agencies or seeking out careers in entirely different fields altogether. 

Still, Colchester has a substantial composition of young officers now and fewer experienced folks on staff than it did in recent years, given its recent wave of attrition and retirements. 

“As our supervision and management has become less experienced and younger, that's not a bad thing, but there's always going to be growing pains,” Hull said. “We're certainly not immune to those. But we've kept our head above water and learned and I think we are gaining on it.” 

Promotions are coming in a few weeks, he said, with a second member coming to the command staff, or the management of the department, as another Lieutenant. CPD is also currently in the process of looking at hiring a non-sworn civilian supervisor for communications and records. Additionally, CPD will be promoting two sergeants to the supervision staff, Hull told the Sun. 

There are 10 non-sworn civilian staff members who work for CPD: six communications specialists, two records clerks and one criminal identification evidence technician, as well as a new hire to fill the aforementioned support services manager position.

“Last year we saw impressive change at the police department,” Hull said at the Dec. 12 selectboard meeting. “We had 182 years of institutional knowledge walk out the door — and you don’t replace that.” 

Some of the most experienced losses included the retirements of former Chief Doug Allen and Deputy Chief Jeff Barton, both of whom had 39 years of experience individually, as well as the loss of a lieutenant and two sergeants, all with well over 30 years of experience each. 

“Fortunately for us, all have made themselves available when we have needed them, each one has contributed something since they left,” Hull said. “And that says something about the dedication that this town gets from its police department, the career people.” 

Colchester’s department also lost two young officers this past year, one of whom went to work for a federal agency and the other of whom moved to Missouri so his wife could attend medical school. 

Due to the staffing shortage, CPD has had to reduce the school unit down to just one officer to cover all the schools in the district and shrink the detective bureau down to one working detective and one supervisor plus the civilian evidence technician, while the other detective is instead filling a patrol division. 

However, despite persistent staffing issues over the course of the last several years, the department has not had to reduce the level of services it provides since the Sun covered the state of staffing shortages at CPD back in 2022, Hull said. 

“It may take a little longer, but we still provide the service,” Hull told the Sun. “It's really been something that we've strived to do because the community is a great community and providing them with the level of service that they deserve is important.” 

Positives for the department in recent years include having added a public safety dispatcher in 2017; a senior leadership position to reduce future leadership changes in 2018; partnering with the Howard Center’s Community Outreach Program in 2018; having added a police officer in 2019; body worn cameras in 2021; introducing more collaboration with Milton, Hinesburg and increasing staffing for community outreach in 2021; adding a civilian criminal identification technician position in 2022 and adding the support services manager to the team in 2023. 

The CPD Chittenden Unit for Special Investigations detective is out on medical leave doing light duty for the time being, but will be back to full duty in a couple of months. 

“It’s not doom and gloom,” Hull said at last month’s selectboard meeting. “It’s easy to think it is, but it really isn't. This is an opportunity for the police department. We're going to build a framework of our future on the foundation that's been made already.” 

The wave of anticipated retirements — about eight in the last three years — is now over, and the department is adjusting and looking to the future. 

“We're hiring new people,” Hull said at the meeting. “It's going to be slow and it's not just because the applicant pool is tough, but we have to maintain our standards. If we started letting our — desperation is the wrong word — but our desire to fill our positions as quickly as possible and we let our standards slip, we're hiring future problems and we can't we can't do that.” 

Hull also sees the state of the force now as an opportunity to make way for the empowerment of fresh, new ideas of young professionals who do come in, eager to learn and collaborate. 

“You want a healthy balance in your department,” he told the Sun in an interview. “It's good for there to be movement and for opportunities for officers to grow within their career as others phase out. It's all part of a natural process for a department, so it is healthy to have turnover.” 

“We had a huge bubble because of the age of our department and how and how it grew,” he added, in regards to the pacing of this process. “That's what caused that bubble. We probably wouldn't see that again, as far as retirements go, a big bubble like that.” 

Furthermore, CPD is far from alone in being impacted by a shortage of staff. 

Vermont’s worker shortage across sectors is ranked in the “most severe” possible category by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s standards. The impacts of this worker shortage have been seen nationwide, with 15 other states also experiencing the “most severe” impacts. 

Vermont has 36 available workers for every 100 open jobs, with 18,000 job openings in total and 6,407 unemployed workers. The labor force participation rate in Vermont is 64%, with an unemployment rate of 1.8%, a quit rate of 2.3% and a hiring rate of 3.6%. 

The labor market in Vermont was stable prior to the pandemic, with 58 workers for every 100 open jobs. Still, the state’s unemployment rate was already far lower than the national figure at 3.5% and its labor force participation rate was marginally higher than the national rate of 63.4%. 

Though Vermont has a notably low unemployment rate, its labor force participation rate is two full points lower than it was in February of 2020, which is particularly concerning for employers, according to the Chamber of Commerce. 

As of the last U.S. Chamber of Commerce evaluation in August 2023, Vermont’s current labor market has not yet recovered since the pandemic’s onset, and the state’s worker shortage lags far behind both its own pre-pandemic levels and the nation’s current average. 

The proposed budget for the coming fiscal year to hit the ballot in March will maintain the current level of services provided and include additional fiscal resources to address the current and future needs of the police department more efficiently and effectively, as assessed by the town. 

The proposed allocation of funds intends to also improve attraction and retention for officers in the department in light of both adjusting to recent retirements of experienced leadership as well as in light of an employee turnover rate which has been heightened “due to societal changes,” said Deputy Town Manager Renae Marshall at the Dec. 12 selectboard meeting. 

Other police force needs cited in last month’s selectboard budget discussion include managing expanding public safety needs, such as uptick in cybersecurity threats.

#csnltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here