Colchester schools’ proposed budget is clear, tax implications remain foggy for now

Posted

Editor's note: This story was updated Feb. 8 at 1:20 p.m. to clarify the role of one of the two new full-time employees added in next year's proposed budget. 

COLCHESTER — The Colchester School Board approved the proposed district budget at its Jan. 16 meeting, but last night discussed concerns about the state’s new funding formula. 

The proposed fiscal year 2025 budget is $57,425,957, a 9.59% increase from FY24, with one of the biggest changes for the coming year having been the addition at Colchester Middle School of a 504 educator to handle the caseload and a multi-language educator to support a projected influx of newcomers having moved to the U.S. with little to no English proficiency. 

Inflation and the increasing costs of health insurance for staff have also contributed to CSD’s budgetary growth. Otherwise, administrators and the school board say they’ve exercised restraint in their budget-building process and made an effort to minimize expenditures, despite most of its schools experiencing facility challenges. Statewide, construction and deferred school maintenance is a $6.3 billion problem. 

While Colchester said it was fiscally responsible, it’s likely a majority of other districts in the state may not be able to say the same. 

The Act 127 problem

In light of Act 127 and its unique school funding formula, it’s possible some districts viewed the changes as an opportunity to cash in, with legislators fearful that many packed extra spending into their budgets, leaving a vast discrepancy between the amount of money schools say they need to budget and the actual ability to fund them without drastic increases in taxation. 

Now, lawmakers at the Statehouse are discussing these unforeseen and unintended consequences of Act 127 — an act intending to make the distribution of public education funds more equitable by changing the weighting of each pupil and subsequently directing more education dollars toward students whose needs are more expensive to support. 

According to Feb. 6 VTDigger reporting, legislators may push back school budget votes to reconsider the aspect of the act that likely led to the mess in question: Act 127’s universal 5% tax cap on homestead property tax rate increases, regardless of each district’s budget size. 

The tax cap inadvertently incentivized many districts to inflate their budgets, likely with well-meaning intent to provide the best for their students. The idea behind increasing budgets being local taxpayers wouldn’t be burdened with immediately spiked tax rates regardless. 

However, the funding will need to come from somewhere if all enlarged budgets are approved, and that somewhere will have to be Vermont’s taxpayers — in other words, it is impossible for the consequences of such a shift to vanish into thin air. 

Lawmakers may replace the controversial tax cap with a new tax “discount” that would apply only to districts losing “taxing capacity,” according to VTDigger’s reporting on a House Ways and Means and House Education Committee joint meeting on Tuesday. 

With lawmakers planning to once again adjust the details that govern the state’s education funding system, the proposal to extend districts’ budgetary voting deadlines to be after Town Meeting Day — which is just a month away — will allow districts time to redraft their budgets. 

Whether or not the discount replaces the tax cap, the latest modeling if all school districts’ currently proposed budgets were to remain unedited and pass, indicates Vermonters on average can expect education property tax bills to increase roughly 20% to support education spending, as economists predict spending could increase nearly 15% next year. 

So what does this mean in terms of property taxes for Colchester residents? 

The answer may be disappointing: Only time will tell. 

If the original plan for the 5% tax cap remains in place, CSD as a low-spending district qualifies without external review by the Secretary of Education — that check being a stipulation essentially aimed at preventing schools with considerably large budgets from taking more than their fair share of tax dollars from taxpayers in other parts of the state. 

If the tax cap stays, the FY25 proposed budget would generate a residential homestead tax rate increase of 5% before applying the common level of appraisal. 

But at this point, with the state considering the modification of that system, local taxation implications are still practically impossible to predict. 

Colchester’s school budget

What we do know is Colchester School District plans to remain a low-spending district and to stick to the budget warned at the previous meeting, with a commitment to providing high-quality education in a manner that values all tax dollars provided by taxpayers, Minor said. 

In FY23 and FY24, Colchester was the lowest-spending school district in Chittenden County, according to superintendent Amy Minor’s budget presentation, and has consistently been one of the two lowest spending districts over the course of the last decade. 

“Historically, this board has had a strong commitment to stretching every penny that the Colchester taxpayers allow you to use as far as we possibly can,” Minor said Feb. 6.

Additionally, CSD has been well below the state average of equalized spending per pupil by district when that was the unit of measurement pre-Act 127. 

Over the past decade, Colchester taxpayers have averaged an annual increase of just 1.53% in education taxes, with two of those years having decreased taxes. 

Factors like the unfinalized drop in dollar yield and drop in Common Level of Appraisal this year, as well as the generally abnormal impacts of the transition to a new funding formula, are entirely outside of the school district’s control, despite how they might contribute to increased tax rates and ultimately reflect on the district. 

“As crazy as this seems, this is the process,” George Trieb, CSD business and operations manager, said last night. “Somewhere in May we find out what the actual various variables are, which the actual tax rate is going to be. It's well after the process, which I know makes little sense but that's the way it is every year [...] it's a guessing game.” 

Still, if the 5% cap were dropped altogether, CSD and all school districts would face a much larger change than usual. 

Regardless, planned spending at Colchester’s schools will stay the course with its proposed budget, expanding intentionally only in areas where the district deems it truly necessary in relation to its student needs, school officials say. 

With steady enrollment in the district and housing growth in the area, as well as committed and qualified teachers educating class sizes just barely meeting or right below the Vermont Educational Quality Standard, it is impossible to reduce staffing or other provisions while maintaining high quality education. 

Student data, behavior and performance demonstrate a clear need for the support staff within the district, Minor said. Another factor to note is the increase in student homelessness at CSD over time and the wish to support those students, the figure for which is currently 95 in the district, though the figure is also high throughout the state. 

The district’s top priority is to maintain existing levels of professional staffing, with seventy-eight percent of the school budget is salaries and benefits. 

Over the past eight years, CSD has slowly increased multilingual educator support staff from 1.5 full-time educators to 4 full-time educators across the district — however, already their capacity is strained, unable to meet the needs of the current 31 newcomers they have district-wide. 

The district has strong community partnerships with local refugee agencies to predict and place students appropriately, and has been told by Vermont’s refugee resettlement program to expect more newcomers in the next academic year, as Colchester has been designated as one of three resettlement sites for an influx of Afghan families slated to arrive soon in the state, leading the school board to opt for the addition of a multi-language support educator.

The added licensed special educator for 504 students next year is necessary so that appropriately trained specialists can design 504 lessons and manage 504 plans for the approximately 40 students at CMS who qualify, and school counselors can instead focus on proactively counseling students. 

At the next school board meeting Feb. 20, when more legislative information becomes available, the Colchester School Board will film an explanatory budget video with LCATV. 

Stay tuned for more coverage on the CSD proposed budget and the implications of the new funding formula implicated by Act 127, as well as what legislators are doing to work out its kinks.

#csnltop, #act 127, #colchester school budget, #fy25

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here