At its Nov. 16 meeting, the Colchester School Board unanimously agreed to prohibit the open session reading of emails submitted to the school board unless read by the author or a person designated by the author.
The board unanimously approved the motion after a robust discussion about accessibility as well as what addressing the board at a public meeting means.
Previously the board allowed submitted emails to be read by either school board members or district employees as part of the public comment period.
School Board Chair Craig Kenny first offered some history, saying that before the COVID-19 pandemic the public could contact the board or any member directly through different mediums, but addressing the board at the meeting had to be in person.
This all changed when the pandemic forced meetings into virtual spaces.
School Board Clerk Nic Longo cited Vermont public meeting law which states:
“At an open meeting, the public shall be given a reasonable opportunity to express its opinion on matters considered by the public body during the meeting, as long as order is maintained."
Longo said the definition of “reasonable opportunity” has expanded in recent years because of digital methods of joining the meeting.
Longo requested that written statements no longer be read aloud because they bring potential discomfort and awkwardness for the person reading the letter as well as the possibility for the meaning to be misinterpreted because of a different tone and cadence from the reader.
Instead, Longo suggested the submission of video recordings or live video directly from the participant instead of a letter being read by someone else
“I’m super open to including as many people as possible into the conversation, but I think it needs to come from the person, the member of the public directly to the board in some fashion,” Longo said
The full approved motion as written in the meeting’s draft minutes reads
“Director Yousey-Hindes moved to prohibit the open session reading of emails submitted to the school board unless read by the author or a proxy, and moved to expressly allow the playing of prerecorded messages if they are received by noon on the day of the meeting and follow the board’s Public Comment Rules as listed on the school board website. He also moved that the board begin the process of preparing a policy and associated procedures to govern citizens’ participation for the Colchester School board.”
The board also discussed public comment more generally and how to make participation as accessible as possible.
Currently, the board does not offer live virtual participation over programs like Zoom.
Board member Ben Yousey-Hindes made a distinction for what addressing the board, speaking at a meeting means.
Yousey-Hindes said the board should bear in mind that the question of how they should allow the public to participate in their public meeting is really a question of how constituents can make their questions and concerns public.
The distinction lies in that anyone has the right and ability to communicate their concerns and questions directly to any board member through various channels, Yousey-Hindes said.
“This is not a question of whether or not we are inviting or allowing or limiting people’s ability to talk to us, it’s actually a question of whether we limit their ability to talk to other people, to talk to the audience that’s watching,” he said.
Board Vice Chair Lindsey Cox said she has made it a goal to expand participation in meetings since she first joined the board and supported allowing people to attend virtually.
She brought up the example of a single mom at home with their child who wants to participate but can’t leave home.
“If they shoot us an email and say ‘Hey, I have a three minute comment, I would like to share it at citizen participation tonight, is there a way for me to do that without leaving my home?’ I would like to be able to say yes to that,” she said.
Superintendent Amy Minor emphasized the importance of having clear and consistent expectations and procedures for the public before the board allows participation over Zoom.
She recommended the board work on drafting a citizens participation policy as the board starts to think about changing its current practices.
The board agreed and is currently looking into policy drafting for the future.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here