COLCHESTER — Colchester School District’s school board answered community questions Tuesday night about the proposed $115 million bond to renovate facilities.
Up for voter consideration Nov. 5, the bond would revitalize the preschool program by getting the district’s youngest learners into more developmentally-appropriate facilities. The project would also expand certain school buildings to meet the demand of a growing student body, as well as enhance safety features and fix a range of deferred maintenance.
Some of the biggest challenges in the district currently are failing heating, ventilation and air conditioning systems, outdated electrical set-ups not conducive to the use of necessary modern-day learning technologies, poor plumbing and other mechanical issues which have flooded out classrooms not infrequently in already-cramped learning environments — on a good day, administrators say, students are often learning in closets and entryways for lack of traditional classroom space.
Union Memorial School and Porters Point School, both of which were built in the mid-1950s, haven’t seen any major renovations since the turn of the century. Colchester Middle School has received zero major renovations since it was established in 1968. These three buildings would be the primary recipients of the funds from the bond, as they are in the most dire need of work.
To read more specifics about the bond itself, the details surrounding the needs it will address, the construction timeline, the history of work leading up to it and more, click here.
To learn more about remaining formal pre-election opportunities to engage with the school board and administration in educational conversation about the bond, click here.
As presented Tuesday night, the bond, if approved, would be repaid over a 30-year period and will be eased in over the first five years and then gradually lowered over the remaining term as the principal amount borrowed gets reduced. If passed, the district’s annual payment would be $5.9 million on average and would be included in the operational spending budget each year.
The average home in Colchester is assessed at a value of $350,000. Without a property tax credit — or for those with household incomes above $128,000 annually — the property tax impact of the passage of this bond would be as follows:
2027: $43 for the year or about $4 per month
2028: $121 for the year or about $10 per month
2029: $330 for the year or about $28 per month
2030: $534 for the year or about $45 per month
2031: $733 for the year or about $61 per month
Starting in 2032, the bond payment will decrease slightly each year as the principal loan balance is paid down.
In addition to the school board, Superintendent Amy Minor and supporting administrators, architects from Black River Designs (the contractor working on the project) also fielded questions and made note of concerns Tuesday night.
Minor said these facility needs aren’t going away, but costs are continuing to climb, so moving forward on the work will be the best mechanism to keep total prices down in the long run.
People have asked why not build one whole new facility to merge the two current early elementary schools with one preschool, but the results of community feedback and a traffic study demonstrated the current plan to keep and update the existing neighborhood schools is more favorable, both with respect to practicality as well as the charm of tradition, Minor said.
Feedback from attendees who spoke up at the meeting was largely positive in the sense that folks who saw the presentation understood the severity of addressing this need in Colchester’s schools, and many individuals expressed gratitude for the attention to detail the plan entails.
However, despite their acknowledgement of the initiative’s importance, several people in attendance expressed a simultaneous concern about affordability, in a town with nearly half of its student body alone below the poverty line, also home to many older folks on fixed incomes.
One attendee pointed out, given the above realities, rent prices will likely be raised for tenants already struggling to make ends meet, as their landlord’s property taxes are raised, resulting in the possibility of longstanding Colchester residents being pushed out of town altogether.
The additional burdens of paying off the bond over the course of the next three decades would be impossible for some residents to manage, he said, on top of what are widely considered to be already-drastic base level tax increases hitting residents each year across the board.
One person suggested reconfiguring the already-finalized ballot item to a smaller bond only inclusive of absolute essential updates and eliminating “nice-to-have” frills, but three district teachers in attendance, who also live in town — one of whom expressed a fear of never being able to retire — still reiterated all needs to be addressed by the bond are too dire to slim down.
Teachers acknowledged affordability concerns, but said the flooding and lack of space they and their colleagues deal with on a day-to-day basis must be addressed, not to mention illnesses caused by buildings with degraded HVAC systems.
One teacher went further to suggest that despite the high monetary price of the work, the number of facility improvements currently selected to be funded by the bond is still too scant.
One of the other teachers in the room attested broadly that none of the problems or necessary fixes the board mentioned were hyperbolized.
The board told one resident in attendance it had already factored inflation, projected cost increases over time and contingencies into the equation determining the total project cost, with the help of professional cost estimators.
Despite the stalling of the state’s polychlorinated biphenyl toxin testing process in schools, the school board also informed residents in attendance that none of its construction projects will move forward without first being cleared with PCB testing for any given building, the testing for which should be completed by 2027. One of CSD’s buildings has been cleared already.
The middle school is slated next for state PCB testing, and this facilities improvement plan and accompanying strategy would be adjusted accordingly if dangerous levels of PCBs were discovered in CMS, CSD business and operations manager George Trieb said at the meeting.
An architect in the audience with no connection to the schools spoke up to thank the board for the incredible amount of planning that goes into such a meticulously organized renovation process, and expressed gratitude to district teachers braving current working conditions.
Dick Pecor, who lives on Middle Road, spoke up to share his belief that public, local institutions generally have an unfortunate tendency to put off crucial facilities work until conditions are so bad they’re jeopardizing the wellbeing of those using them, and encouraged a mindset change, with consideration to such problems as they’re gradually snowballing, moving forward.
The school board has been working on plans to address deferred maintenance in the most cost-effective way it could for years, but put its plans on hold during the height of the pandemic.
Another Colchester resident in attendance who works in water quality said he used to be a town planner, at which point the CMS and MBS parking lot was expanded with no accommodation for additional drainage, which he said resulted in the blow-out of a ravine behind CMS, dumping tons of sediment into Smith Creek and Lake Champlain.
He said there is no doubt in his mind the work to be funded by the bond is essential, but wanted the board to keep caution in mind while increasing impervious surfaces around school buildings.
Another resident pointed out safety code isn’t flimsy or imaginary, but necessary, expressing the importance of the bond in keeping buildings up to code and ensuring the district is no longer sending staff and students into unsafe, unsecured areas, in the event of a shooting — which did indeed happen in the 2000s right next door in Essex, an event he said “tore the town apart.”
Another teacher in the audience said her classroom, too small to hold her 24 kids and lacking an adequate emergency exit, said she thinks every day about how she’d hide her kids in the case of a real-life emergency. She, too, has had her classroom flooded while teaching.
Someone else shared a deep appreciation for the board’s holistic, long-term thinking in doing the work all at once and paying it back via a bond, noting if the district were to piecemeal each individual required fix over years, rising prices would cost taxpayers more in the long run.
“The investment we make today pays dividends tomorrow,” he said.
He also suggested congressional legislative earmarks to partially fund the project. Others, too, expressed acknowledgement of how severe the need is to invest in the schools, but also the sentiment the town’s residents can’t afford it — and a desire, need even, for state-level support.
On the subject of alternative funding sources, Minor did mention earlier in the presentation it is not legally possible to utilize the town’s local option tax to assist with this project, and that there are no formal state funds currently available to aid with school construction.
Another attendee mentioned the level to which the district fails to meet ADA compliance standards is severe, and she applauded the board for being proactive about addressing those needs, because if it weren’t done proactively, those needs would be addressed through litigation, which is more expensive and tears the social fabric of communities apart, she said.
An early childhood special educator in the district expressed her own concerns over how to keep her kids safe should a security breach happen, and also recognized the lack of ADA compliance currently in place, which has an unfair impact on many children’s learning.
The final day for free facility tours is tomorrow, Oct. 5, from 9 a.m. until noon, with no appointment required to participate. Other engagement opportunities can be found here.
Those who have read the Sun’s previous coverage and are still wanting more, a video and visual projected maps and designs, can be found at csdbond.org.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here