Correction 9:27 a.m. Wednesday, July 30: This article has been updated to reflect that the petition submitted by Attorney Simon was received and not accepted by the board and that the decision about the preliminary plat will be made in the next 45 days.
COLCHESTER — Colchester residents have had their say about Hazelett’s proposed inn in Mallets Bay.
“I'm really concerned about small businesses and our quality of life here in Colchester,” Kelly Mancini Becker said. “This is our community, and I want to be able to get to the highway within a reasonable amount of time.”
She is not the only resident with these concerns. All 18 people who spoke out at the Development Review Board’s last public hearing on the project July 23 had similar worries. All expressed concern and disapproval regarding its potential traffic and environmental impacts.
The inn and restaurant would be located across the street from the current Hazelett facility on West Lakeshore Drive if approved.
The proposed project features four lakeside buildings with 19 guest rooms, ranging from studio units to one- and two-bedroom suites. A 48-seat restaurant, event and meeting space to accommodate conferences and a designated lakeside recreational area are also part of the proposal.
The main changes to the project from the last meeting include the removal of the manager’s suite to add a two-bedroom guest suite, adding a pedestrian crossing with flashing lights across West Lakeshore Drive and including a 26-foot easement to the town to include space for a ten foot recreational path.
This was the board’s fourth and last public hearing on the project. The project is in phase two — preliminary plat approval — of three. Two consultants, Benjamin Avery of Greenfield Growth and Scott Homsted of Krebs & Lansing Consulting Engineers, represented the property owner at the meeting.
Several members of the public were concerned about how the Malletts Bay Sewer Project would impact development along the lake.
“This application is the first of what will no doubt be a steady stream of applications coming for development coming along West Lakeshore Drive, given the installation of the sewer line,” Jeanette Barry said. “I encourage you to please tread carefully.”
Phyllis Bryden was worried about how the project could impact the pace of construction for the sewer project.
“All of a sudden we're not getting any work done on East Lakeshore Drive,” she said. “Is all that stuff being held up because we're waiting for these guys to be put on the system?”
After confirming that the projects are on separate schedules with DRB Chair Matthew Gamage, Bryden asked about the accessibility features of the inn.
Avery said the project would feature a circular driveway for dropping people off, nearby handicap parking and the main building with the restaurant would be ADA compliant — but not all the guest rooms.
Homestead said the State of Vermont has special requirements for accessibility that are addressed through the permitting process.
“Professional architecture firms work very hard to be sure that all of the grading, all of the access, all the requirements and the appropriate number of ADA units and accessibility are addressed at this stage,” he said.
Residents were also worried about losing views and experiences of the lake.
“[There’s] too much brick, too much steel, too many buildings,” Carl Cloutier said. “This will essentially create a many 100 foot long wall, 30 or 40 feet high, that will not ever, regardless of what season it is, allow a view of the lake.”
He reflected on viewing the site from his car during a time he was stopped on West Lakeshore Drive due to construction.
“I was surrounded by the old forest trees,” he said. “I could not see broad pieces of lake right where I was sitting – but you know there's a lake there.”
Cloutier, who shared he is 72 years-old, said the project would destroy that experience for longer than he will be a resident of Colchester.
Attorney Bryce Simon attended the meeting on behalf of a group of community members to submit a petition in hopes of establishing a legal claim against the board at a later date. The petition was recieved by the board.
Simon said the group believes the site is being maximized to the detriment of water quality and views, as well as not fitting the legal requirements of being an inn.
“As I pointed out in my letter, the diagram of the type of building that you'd like on this lot is sort of a narrow building where you can see very easily to the lake,” he said. “Even though I understand this board is not responsible for stormwater permitting, or for maybe all the water quality requirements the state and the feds have, it is within your zoning bylaws to determine if they're harming water quality, and if they are, you don't have to give them a permit.”
Homestead said he did not want to debate legal definitions of what the property owner was doing in a public forum.
“We have submitted floor plans for staff review with a recommendation to the board, and it is really up to staff the board with any advice or counsel on whether or not our application and our designs meet the definition,” he said.
The board adjourned the meeting at 10:56 p.m. shortly after public comment, with a determination to make a decision within 45 days after the meeting.
The next meeting is slated for 7 p.m. Wednesday, August 13. It will be held at the third floor conference room of the Colchester Town Offices and remotely on livestream 3 on LCATV.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here