Colchester hit with $120,000 legal fee; Courts rule condemnation done in ‘bad faith’

Posted

COLCHESTER – A civic court ruling released last month finds the Town of Colchester partially liable for the legal fees of Mongeon Bay Properties, following eminent domain proceedings the town undertook to build out stormwater infrastructure.

The latest order released by the Vermont Superior Court requires the town to pay Mongeon a total of $122,144.50 in legal fees after the courts originally ruled Colchester was acting in “bad faith” to secure the property.

Previously this spring, Judge Samuel Hoar found Colchester’s effort to acquire the Mongeon land, located at 885 East Lakeshore Drive, was “a pretextual” and “driven not by the careful analysis of costs and benefits … but by the desire to remove … a thorn in the Town’s side.”

“This, of course, is impermissable,” he added.

Throughout the condemnation process, the Town of Colchester argued they needed the property for a stormwater improvement after a breakdown occurred on the property back in 2019, leading to worries of another repeated costly event and more flooding problems for the neighborhood.

Dealing with stormwater

According to court documents, the town’s initial effort to acquire a section of the Mongeon Bay Properties holdings began in 2019. That year, a stormwater drainpipe on the property ended up bursting during a rainstorm, which led to the two entities pointing fingers to find who was responsible for the damages.

The resulting legal case – after a few sessions in mediation – resulted with Mongeon Bay Properties paying the town $62,500 to cover its costs while requiring the company make some improvements to the property.

Town Manager Aaron Frank said by email the funds represented “the largest zoning violation fine or settlement” he is aware of in Colchester.

The problems, however, continued. Roughly a year later, a gravel berm was erected near the catch-basin entrance which threatened to overwhelm the pipe.

At the time, the device effectively trapped and pushed all the rainwaters through the problematic stormwater infrastructure. Additionally, the town argued the extra water load and lack of maintenance to keep the pipe clean of debris also put the camp and property in danger of further problems, including potential collapse.

The problems – in combination, the town argued – led to the administration initiating condemnation hearings to find a stormwater solution.

Much of the underlying difficulty about the property stems from the actual pipe layout. Since 1979, the Town of Colchester has had an easement agreement with the owners, Mongeon Bay Properties, which gave town access to a strip of land 10-feet wide which is underneath the constructed camp at 885 Lakeshore Drive. There underground, a corrugated pipe feeds water from a catchbasin that eventually ends up moving down through an outflow pipe on the beach.

Town officials expressed concerns about erosion underneath the property that goes unseen. Without a long-term fix to the issue, the town argued maintenance costs could also prove detrimental.

Colchester ended up reaching out to Mongeon Bay Property owners to gauge if there was any interest in selling the camp to the town. The lack of response then led to the more complicated legal mechanism of eminent domain.

“The Town attempted to negotiate a voluntary sale of 885 East Lakeshore Drive, for fair market value, from Mongeon Bay Properties to reduce the human risk and reduce the Town’s liability,” Frank said via email. “The Town initiated condemnation of 885 East Lakeshore Drive primarily for these reasons.”

In theory, by condemning the property due to existing stormwater issues, the town could engineer a fix which would make its unique geography into an advantage for the town. That resulting stormwater improvement facility, however, was estimated to cost $1.6 million.

Condemnation

By January 2022, the Colchester Selectboard had officially moved forward with condemning the property, citing the town’s legal arguments.

The latest ruling by Judge Samuel Hoar, however, offered a different take on the earlier proceedings. In his legal opinion on the case, Hoar directly tied the town’s condemnation actions to the earlier 2019 incident and the resulting legal snafus, while arguing its efforts to create a stormwater solution had been stretched to meet the administration’s needs in order to remove a “thorn.”

Ultimately, Hoar compared the effort to removing an arm and replacing it with a prosthetic in order to scratch an itch.

As evidence, the judge pointed to a 2017 study of stormwater options undertaken by Colchester as well as its 2020 phosphorus control plan. Both studies identified dozens of potential sites where stormwater infrastructure could be installed, but Hoar said the Mongeon property was "conspicuously absent” from both lists.

“The credible evidence establishes that the town undertook no careful analysis of either the costs or anticipated benefits of stormwater treatment at the property – much less a comparison of those costs and benefits with those associated with other treatment options,” he wrote.

And under state law, the necessity of condemning a property requires the legal lynchpin. Mere difficulty and financial strain can’t be the only reason a town moves forward with an eminent domain action.

Mongeon’s lawyers also disproved the town’s arguments that it would even lead to cost savings in the first place.

By the court’s estimation, the final project that had been planned for the property would have cost taxpayers close to $500,000 for every pound of phosphorus removed. Mongeon’s expert engineering witness, meanwhile, had presented their own stormwater project that could be installed nearby and would eliminate the same amount of pollutant from the lake at 10% of the cost.

“It is clear … that there are better locations, and treatment methodologies that not only better conform to best engineering practices but yield demonstrably better results at a far lower cost,” Hoar ruled. “ … In short, the alternative design provides far greater benefit to that taxpayer than the Project, by any means."

Instead, Hoar ruled the town was acting in “bad faith” when it began its condemnation hearings, pointing to arguments between Mongeon and town representatives that grew increasingly testy as they progressed.

In 2017, for example, the property holder was part of a large-scale eviction of multiple people who had formed a long-term lease with Mongeon as the Mallets Bay Homeowners Association. The resulting controversy from the mass eviction likely hurt the town’s reputation.

It also created increased tension between the two entities, according to the courts, helping to taint the town’s ongoing interactions with Mongeon around 885 East Lakeshore Drive.

“The Town presented no credible evidence as to the benefits of the Project as compared with its costs,” the court ruled.

As a result of the “bad faith” categorization, Mongeon appealed for legal fees to cover the court case, which were granted by Vermont’s civic court. The property owner asked for close to $200,000, but after a careful examination of the arguments, the final ruling settled on roughly $120,000.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here