Colchester Historical Society honors Women’s History Month with speaker-led event

Posted

COLCHESTER — The Colchester Historical Society welcomed longtime member and lawyer Jack Penca to lead its monthly meeting Saturday to present “A Treatment of American Women by the Legal System.” 

Throughout his talk, he provided a timeline of the progress for women in the U.S. legal system “from near invisibility” all the way up to their current-day status. 

“It's women's history month this month — so welcome, especially to all the ladies here,” said Bonnie Potter, president of the Colchester Historical Society at the opening of the meeting. “I think we all each have our own little history.” 

“And it's interesting, isn't it, that we have a man as our speaker,” she added, and the crowd erupted into laughter. “I've heard he's had some good training from his daughter and his wife.”

In relation to the legal system itself, Penca has also had some good training in the more formal sense, as a graduate of Notre Dame Law School and with career experience as a prosecutor, immigration attorney and an administrative law judge. 

“As a lawyer, I do have a professional interest in women and the law, but as a husband, father and grandfather, I do have personal interest as well,” Penca said. “It was fun doing the research and I learned so much and have a greater appreciation for what women had to contend with and overcome to reach the point where they are today.” 

Though he said there were too many aspects of women in the law throughout history to cover in his brief talk, he did focus on women’s property rights, women in education and women in politics, honing in on a few anecdotes and examples of specific women who paved the way for others to come. 

“American Women's property rights were giving some economic independence, but they were still subject to their husbands in other ways,” Penca said of the mid-19th century. “And one of them was women being involuntarily committed to mental institutions because they expressed opinions or they behaved in ways that were not accepted.” 

In 1853, Illinois passed a statute stating that before a person could be involuntarily committed to a mental institution, they had to have a public hearing — though the law had the one major exception, allowing husbands to institutionalize their wives without the woman’s consent. 

In 1860, a woman by the name of Elizabeth Packard was involuntarily committed by her husband at the Jacksonville, Illinois insane asylum, Penca said, the reason for it being she had questioned his beliefs and expressed opinions that he didn't like. 

She was there for three years, during which time she refused to admit that she was insane and she refused to change her opinions. 

“Finally, the staff doctor said she was incurable and they released her,” he said — this point in the story eliciting more laughter from the crowd. “But that was not the end of Elizabeth's story.” 

Sadly, her husband then took her back home and confined her to the house, Penca said. She managed to get a letter out to a friend, and as a result of her letter, she was given a hearing to determine her sanity, with numerous witnesses and five days of testimony. 

“An all male jury took seven minutes to declare her sane,” Penca said. 

Unfortunately for Packard, by the time she returned from her trial, her husband had rented out their shared home, sold all the furniture, stolen all of her belongings and run off to live in Massachusetts — another state in which she had no legal recourse — with their six children, leaving her with nothing. 

Packard spent the rest of her life writing and campaigning for better mental health laws, and she had some success in 1867, at which point Illinois passed a law that finally said a married woman could have a hearing before involuntarily being committed by her husband. 

“Too late for her, and she suffered greatly for it, but I think she's a remarkable woman,” Penca said. “Terrible things happened to her but she went on and devoted her life to try and make things better for other people.” 

After discussions of women’s representation in some fields requiring higher education, with engineering numbers being notably low even today, a few folks in attendance at the meeting shared their personal experiences with sexism in the workplace as well. 

Historical society member and attendee Fran Bailey, who was a career engineer at IBM, said she had been on loan to the Glendale lab in Endicott in 1968 — at which point in time, there were no women’s bathroom facilities, she said. Only men’s. 

“So if I had to go to the bathroom, I had to have a man go with me and stand [guard] outside,” Bailey said. “The other thing is, your manager had a right with women to do a bra check, to make sure you had a bra, because it was the era of ‘burn the bra.’” 

“This is in my lifetime,” she added. “And it's recent and, well, things haven't changed that much.” 

Among the handouts passed around at the meeting’s conclusion, was a sheet detailing a number of Historical Firsts presented, a packet including a number of selected historical firsts for women higher education and in politics. 

Today, 58% if college students are women, 21% of engineering students are women, 14% of engineers are women, 56% of law students are women, 37% of lawyers are women, 53% of medical students are women and 37% of doctors are women — while in 1970, 41% of college students were women, fewer than 1% of engineering students were women, 2.8% of lawyers were women and 5% of doctors were women — engineering being one of the fields with the lowest participation rate for women. 

Other information on the handout stated that as of 2023, 12 of 50 state governors are women, 126 of 453 U.S. House representatives are women, 25 of 100 U.S. senators are women, 5 of 15 cabinet members are women and 4 of 9 Supreme Court members are women. 

“Engineering is one of those areas that is very reluctant to change,” Penca said, following Bailey’s comment. “There was a segment on TV that I saw recently that talked about women engineers, and apparently, even though women do graduate from engineering school, many of them drop out in the field because it's very difficult. They're not getting the assignments or not getting the support that their male counterparts are and it becomes very discouraging.” 

Bailey added that IBM was so results-driven she didn’t experience discrimination in terms of jobs or projects, but rather in the surrounding work environment. The reason there weren’t any ladies’ rooms in the lab was because even the secretaries at the time had to be men, she said — as the company said “women had big mouths” and would give away the IBM secrets. 

Following the lecture on many other examples of women in U.S. history navigating the legal system, someone in attendance asked during the group discussion about how women of color and indigenous women fit into the conversation. 

“There are additional hurdles that women of color had to face,” Penca said. “And it's just more than I could get into here. But yes. We have a first for women, then if you look for the first for Black women or for Asian women, you're gonna find it much later.” 

“There are many, many aspects,” he added, on the note of intersectionality. “And you know, there's still things today, barriers that women face.” 

At the end, folks mingled with one another over refreshments and took handouts to go.

#csnltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here