Editor's note: This story was updated on April 23 at 2:55 p.m. to better convey a source's position.
COLCHESTER — The Town of Colchester is terminating its previously-confirmed solar farm project planned for installation on Laura Lane, due to complaints from neighboring residents.
The decision to cancel the project was publicized in an April 8 memo from the town manager’s office, and discussed further at Tuesday night’s selectboard meeting, following what was thought to be a success amidst a series of failed site proposals for other solar farms in town.
Town Manager Aaron Frank terminated the Laura Lane project this week, prior to permitting, upon hearing “the respectful concerns of nearby residents of the town-owned property and how much they value the green space in their neighborhood.”
This solar farm would have become the town’s fifth municipal solar farm and would have made Colchester surpass its goal of offsetting all energy consumed in the provision of municipal services through an equal or greater amount of renewable energy generation.
However, this goal as it currently stands will still be met by the town’s other solar farms even without Laura Lane — even if only for the time being.
“We respect the love for this informal multi-use area that was expressed by the neighborhood residents,” Town Manager Aaron Frank stated in an April 10 email to the Sun. “That is why the project was terminated.”
Eight people shared with the town they did not want a solar farm at the Laura Lane location. Bruce Bourgeois, who lives on Laura Lane, is one of them.
Bourgeois attended Tuesday’s meeting to share his gratitude for the town’s decision to act on his and his neighbors’ opposition to the project, and to reiterate the importance of residents being a part of decision-making processes for new projects in their neighborhoods generally. He spoke up following a presentation on the subject from Assistant Town Manager Renae Marshall.
“A lot of people felt like they weren’t told and I think that comes from — I know there's a process you have in place — but I think if you're reaching out to everybody first ahead of time, to give them a heads up [...] that's going to eliminate a lot of headaches for everybody,” Bourgeois said.
“I don't think anybody truly feels that you're hiding stuff, it's just the timeframe of waiting until the 11th hour before anybody knows about it and they can voice their concerns,” he added. “I think that’s where the feeling comes from.”
Selectboard member Maureen Dakin expressed a different sentiment: that town leaders had followed appropriate procedures, and that it would have been far too early in the process to notify neighbors at the stage the project was in. Dakin told the Sun that if the project had proceeded, notification would have been sent, as is the policy.
“The one thing that bothered me about everything that I've seen and read is that [some people assumed] the town was trying to put something over on people,” she said at Tuesday’s meeting. “[That] people [felt they] weren't notified — [and felt] we were trying to do something behind people's backs.”
On the contrary, Dakin said she’s been very impressed with the transparency and outreach of the town since she’s been on the selectboard and prior to that, and she commended Frank and Marshall on the excellence of their memo in response to this issue.
Frank said at the meeting that eight years ago the town conducted an analysis of many sites in town to figure out where to build, and they intentionally tried to avoid Laura Lane due to its status as a residential neighborhood.
“Since then, we've been told by the Agency of Natural Resources that they don't want to develop away from developed areas,” Frank said. “And so we've really been pushed.”
The town pushed back on the state and contacted multiple officials to express concern over that directive, with Frank having pushed back specifically about the Laura Lane site initially.
“And to be honest, we always knew this was a difficult site,” he said. “And now I just want to say, I respect, Renee respects and our contractor agents respect how much the neighborhood loves that area…and we realized it was time to conclude the project. So I just want to thank people for their input and sharing how important that site is to them.”
In addition to concerns over loss of green space, community members expressed concern over the installation of a solar farm on Laura Lane back in January with regard to impacts it might have had on a stormwater retention pond, pipes and berm that protect neighboring properties from flooding.
Prior to the berm being placed, one resident experienced significant flooding issues. As a result of being made aware, the Town Manager’s office asked the Department of Public Works staff to conduct their own evaluation of the flooding concerns expressed by the resident.
DPW staff met with the resident on site, then began work on their own evaluation of the existing stormwater features and what work was needed to restore or increase the capacity of the stormwater retention pond.
Staff then began work to clear the trees that had grown up within the area of the retention pond and developed plans for improving the pond to address the flooding concerns. DPW has issued a request for bids for this work and intends to award it no later than the end of May 2024 with work to be completed by September 30, 2024.
The Laura Lane project would have allowed the town to exceed the current goal of 720 kilowatts generated in renewable electricity by about 150 kilowatts, or by 20%, but that’s only a fraction of future demand. The project would have resulted in no capital cost to the town thanks largely to a federal investment tax credit and would have saved the town money over time.
“The Town Plan, which was developed by the Colchester Planning Commission with significant community input, and later adopted by the selectboard, includes a goal of producing electrical energy close to the total amount consumed by the Town government,’” Town Manager Aaron Frank stated in his email to the Sun. “The goal, based on current electrical consumption, plus the Recreation Center and the Malletts Bay Sewer, will be met with the completion of the Roosevelt Project and the rooftop and parking lot solar components of the Recreation Center.”
However, he wrote, that goal is not static. Over time, the town will move to transition $240,000 in annual hydrocarbon energy use to electricity in the future, which means that target will increase. An additional solar site of 150 kilowatts, which was up until this week slated to be placed on Laura Lane, would address roughly one sixth of that future electric energy use.
“Due to current federal funding incentives, we can build another 150 kW site without using local tax dollars and also benefit the town financially as well,” Frank stated. “Each site of 150 kW adds about $43,000 in annually recurring revenue to the town budget that decreases the amount of funds which need to be raised by property taxes.”
So what’s next?
Essentially, to go back to the drawing board yet again, and focus efforts on evaluating other town-owned parcels of land in hopes of finding a suitable site.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here