COLCHESTER — As the Vermont legislative session continues to unfold, local input has emerged on a bill pertaining to censorship in libraries.
An avid defender of library collections against book bans, Burnham Memorial Library director Kelly McCagg believes in the purpose of the bill as a whole to protect patrons and materials, as well as its intentions — but there’s just one section of the bill that isn’t sitting right in her mind.
S. 220 fails to delineate expectations of authoritative bodies — meaning what falls on the library’s trustees as opposed to the associated town’s selectboard — between municipal and private libraries, McCagg said.
“I think it could have far reaching ramifications,” she added. “If you look at other states, right now where people are banning materials, it really does matter how well the managing bodies are working together to prevent things like that.”
McCagg has been in touch with the legislature as well as the president and vice president of the Vermont Library Association and the state librarian to make her voice heard and request an amendment. She spoke on the subject at the Colchester selectboard meeting Tuesday night.
“I don't know if you will be moved to write letters yourselves or to reach out to our elected representatives,” she said, addressing the selectboard. “But I thought it was important that you be made aware of what's going on and of the possible controversy that it's going to cause.”
Town Manager Aaron Frank offered to write a letter on behalf of the selectboard to reiterate McCagg’s input in favor of protecting more nuanced authority structures in libraries statewide.
The bill, S.220, would require public libraries to establish procedures for reviewing potential objections to their books and other materials, and would protect patrons ages 12 and up from having their library records disclosed to parents or guardians against their will, as reported by VTDigger. As it stands now, those protections apply only to those age 16 and older.
The bill was amended Tuesday to extend the required policies to schools’ collections, to prevent books from being removed due to identities of characters or an author as well as to protect the inclusion of sexual health content in collections statewide and to prevent bans on books due to “personal morality, political views or religious views.”
Although a 2023 report found that book bans are rare in Vermont compared to other states, library staff here still feel the effects of “soft censorship,” which led to the creation of the bill.
McCagg, Colchester’s library director, hopes the bill will pass — in fact, she herself spent two years volunteering on the working group from which many of the recommendations outlined in S.220 were produced, and she has over 25 years of experience working in public libraries with over 20 years of experience as a library director and over a decade of doing so in Vermont.
“Individuals 12 years of age and older have the right in Vermont to make decisions about their physical and mental health treatment,” McCagg stated in a March 21 letter to the Colchester selectboard. “The same freedom should be given to these individuals when it comes to the materials they borrow from the library. Knowledge is not a privilege; it is an inalienable right.”
But in order for the bill’s passage to be worthwhile in her eyes, McCagg believes changes are needed to Section 6. 22 V.S.A. 143, which she believes fails to address crucial distinctions between municipal libraries and private non-profit libraries that may receive municipal funding.
The section of the bill of concern to McCagg would increase the role, authority and responsibility of municipal library trustees for creating budgets and hiring directors and personnel by removing responsibility and authority for such decisions from the selectboard in any given town.
While McCagg sees this as an honest attempt to clear up misunderstandings around the dynamic between libraries and their affiliated municipalities, she believes this section as written could create divisiveness between library affiliates and town representatives.
“It does not respect the modern reality that municipal government-owned and operated libraries receive significant coordinated services and support from personnel management, human resources, payroll, finance, information technology and building maintenance,” she stated.
McCagg believes it makes no sense for a municipal library to have to establish a new board independent of the selectboard to handle these matters, given that libraries like the Burnham are receiving much needed central support just fine through partnerships with town officials.
Having spoken with Colchester’s town attorney, McCagg believes the language in this section won’t result in negative impacts on Colchester specifically, as the town charter has language noting that staff and department heads, including the library director, are selected by the town manager, and that the selectboard is responsible for the budget that goes before voters.
However, she does worry that the language in this section of the bill would raise questions about such matters, and that prior to passage of the bill, it should be clarified in writing that the section does not apply to towns with charter provisions to the contrary.
“I support this bill, but only if the concerns raised above in Sec. 6 22 V.S.A. 143 are completely addressed,” she stated in the closing lines of her letter.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here