Colchester Rep. Pat Brennan has chaired the Vermont House of Representatives Transportation Committee for nearly a decade. He’s communicated with law enforcement regularly through those years, often receiving briefings after some of the state’s most gruesome vehicle crashes.
Until recently, Brennan was a staunch opponent of a primary seatbelt enforcement law — one that would allow police to pull a driver over solely for not wearing a seat belt. As it stands today, officers can only ticket unbelted drivers after stopping them for a different offense.
Brennan rethought his stance after the state endured a slew of fatal crashes last year. Eight people were killed in collisions during one particularly deadly week in August.
Seven of those eight were unbelted, and 52 percent of the 69 total roadway fatalities in 2017 involved unbelted occupants, according to the Vermont Highway Safety Alliance. Those stats prompted Gov. Phil Scott to “reconsider” his opposition to primary enforcement, too, Vermont Public Radio reported last year.
“My position is, let’s have a discussion,” Brennan said. “Convince me that it’s going to be better for Vermonters to have a primary belt and tell me how it’s going to increase usage, and I’ll probably support it.”
Brennan told some state media outlets he was drafting a primary seatbelt bill himself late last year. That plan was halted after fellow Rep. George Till introduced legislation “identical” to the one he was working on, he explained last week.
With “tremendous” support from many House members, Brennan anticipates the language in Till’s bill will eventually make it into broader highway safety legislation addressing things like distracted driving and work zone protections.
Meanwhile, the legislature’s recent passage of recreational marijuana has drawn significant attention to highway safety in the state, Brennan said, making this an especially poignant time to talk seat belts.
“It’s my committee’s job that we do what we can to keep the road safe,” Brennan said. “This [law] is one of them.”
Studies show seatbelt usage is currently slipping across the state, Brennan said. He recalls 87 to 88 percent of Vermont motorists wearing seat belts at one time. Today, it’s closer to 84 percent, according to Brennan.
Research from other states that have moved from secondary to primary enforcement suggests the change may prompt an estimated 5 percent increase in seat belt use, Brennan said. His committee will hear more testimony about the effects this week.
“We’re heading in the wrong direction there,” Brennan said of the current usage figures. “It’s not a guarantee, but the possibility of going from 85 to 90 percent [seat belt use]? That’s going to save some lives.”
Brennan said law enforcement officials he’s talked to are overwhelmingly supportive of the idea. The way he tells it, many officers wish they could write a ticket just for seat belt misuse and send a message with a minimal fine.
Instead, they have to first ticket and fine drivers for a different violation, like a broken taillight.
The Colchester Republican has traditionally characterized himself as resistant to government reach and has heard from several constituents who think primary seatbelt enforcement infringes on their personal freedoms.
Many of those voters, Brennan said, were unaware it was already illegal to drive unbelted. Others charge that wearing the devices don’t offer absolute protection from a fatal crash.
Brennan acknowledges the latter point, but asserts wearing a seat belt is a small price to pay for even minimally increased chances of survival. Plus, he was rocked to learn Vermont’s serious crashes have amounted to half a billion dollars in economic impact in just the last five years.
“You don’t have a decision after you’re killed or maimed and someone else has to look out for you,” Brennan said. “It’s not just your life. It’s the lives of the rest of the traveling public, too.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here