Editor's note: Book Reviews with the Burnham is a series of book reviews by Burnham Memorial Library staff members on the Sun site every other week.
Barely Floating
By Lilliam Rivera
Middle-grade novel, 2023
While books about young athletes abound, ones about artistic swimming – what most of us probably know as “synchronized swimming” – don’t often pop up on middle grade shelves. Barely Floating, a 2023 novel by Lilliam Rivera, fills that gap. It tells of 12-year-old Nat who discovers the sport at her local pool and decides to dive on in… but not without complications.
The main challenge for Nat is keeping her involvement with artistic swimming a secret from her disapproving parents; her mom especially does not want Nat involved in an activity she feels emphasizes a certain beauty standard.
However, headstrong Nat joins a team anyway. She grows stronger and makes new friends as a member of the LA Mermaids, but soon keeping up the deception strains many of her important relationships.
What is striking about this book is how it holds many complicated ideas and feelings at once, demonstrating that often two somewhat opposing things can both be true. It’s most clearly represented in the generational divide between Nat and her mother, who each have strong feminist personalities and yet perceive the beauty industry and fashion differently.
The pressure to conform to beauty standards that Nat’s mother fears is quite real for many pre-teens, and Nat does indeed field criticisms about her body in her pursuit of artistic swimming. But Nat is also correct in calling out her mom’s judgmental beliefs that an interest in fashion or makeup is related to someone’s intelligence or value.
Thinking back on the recent Paris Olympics, the book calls to mind rugby player Ilona Maher and her “Beast, Beauty, Brains” slogan. Maher has been an outspoken advocate that all those elements can co-exist, and Barely Floating presents a similarly important message to its middle grade audience.
In addition to those themes, the novel is also simply a fun introduction to the sport of artistic swimming. From getting a glimpse of the arduous workout regimens to learning alongside Nat about notable figures in the sport – like classic movie star Esther Williams and more recent Team USA member Anita Alvarez – the book provides readers a chance to bring new perspective the next time artistic swimming is underway at their pool or on their TV screens.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here