The Colchester company Enviro Tech of VT Septic Services was fined $58,550 last week after unlawfully managing septic waste for over a decade, according to the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources.
Enviro Tech of VT has not had a valid waste transporter permit since 2006, a press release from ANR said, but transported and delivered almost 4 million gallons of septic waste between 2012 and 2017.
ANR said Enviro Tech of VT also temporarily stored solid waste on its Colchester property on multiple occasions and failed to submit quarterly reports of “waste management activities and associated fees.”
Randy Duval, the owner and sole employee of Enviro Tech of VT, admitted in an interview last week he had not held the waste transporter permit since 2006. But he said he didn’t receive a violation report until 2016, almost a decade later.
“The guilt goes both ways,” Duval said. “They should have told me. They never said anything to me. I was dumbfounded. I was hit in the side of the head going ‘Where’d this come from, how’d this happen?’”
Duval said he has well over 1,000 clients, mostly in Chittenden County, and disposes waste at a handful of area wastewater treatment plants. His services include septic tank pumping, locating and uncovering septic tanks, septic system inspections, sewage pump station services and rejuvenating failed septic systems, according to the company website.
He said he was late in submitting his most recent 2017 quarterly report, but only because he was stuck waiting for the Shelburne treatment plant to send him confirmation of some figures required on the forms.
Duval provided the Sun with copies of cancelled checks for three of his 2017 quarterly payments and a $175 waste transporter permit, dated May 12, 2017.
Plus, Duval said the charge that he stored solid waste on his property “on multiple occasions” is misleading. In 2016, he said he sometimes would briefly park a partially filled truck in between sewage pickups for efficiency sake, allowing him to make fewer trips back and forth to the treatment plant.
When an ANR official learned of and admonished the practice two years ago, Duval said he was completely transparent about the frequency of his intermittent parking and immediately stopped.
“I have nothing to hide; I’m a very open person,” Duval said. “I’m an honest person.”
The Department of Environmental Conservation regulates commercial companies like Enviro Tech of VT, according to the press release. Not complying with its stated rules gives companies an economic advantage and allows them to earn “wrongful profits,” ANR said.
Kane Smart, a lawyer with ANR, said earlier this week it was certainly possible Duval had not been informed he was in violation until 2016. Still, he said commercial entities bear the responsibility for staying in compliance.
“Vermonters put a lot of trust in our waste haulers, and it’s up to these professionals to maintain that trust by meeting environmental and public safety standards,” DEC commissioner Emily Boedecker echoed in the ANR release.
“When haulers don’t get their waste transporter permit, they’re taking a big risk by endangering Vermonter’s health and our natural environment,” she continued. “This permit is our way of helping the waste haulers conduct their business in a way that protects public health and the environment.”
ANR said it put Enviro Tech of VT “on notice” after discovering the violations. The agency says the company made partial efforts to obtain the required permit and pay backlogged fees, but ultimately failed to return to compliance.
Smart said his agency was unable to negotiate a settlement with Duval and successfully sought a judicial order from the Vermont Superior Court Environmental Division requiring Enviro Tech of VT to stop hauling solid waste until the transporter permit is renewed.
“The ability of one to pay is something that we consider,” Smart said. “But we don’t necessarily take the representation without substantiation.”
Smart said he understands Duval’s window for challenging the fee in court has effectively expired. Duval is also responsible for paying for the outstanding permits in addition to the $58,550 penalty — a cost burden he said would effectively sink his company.
“You do this, I’m out of business,” Duval said. “They’re just playing bully more than anything. It bothers me. If you expect small businesses to survive here, you’re not setting a good example.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here