VERMONT — It’s not surprising that affordability is a problem with as many opinions as potential solutions.
Vermont has long wrestled with how to attract workers, stem work-related demographic declines and build more housing that people can actually afford. Two nonprofits, Better (not bigger) Vermont and Vermont Futures Project, each have their own solutions for how Vermont can address these challenges, all while trying to keep the widely-cherished rural character of the state intact.
These nonprofits make up some of the many voices that are trying to solve complex, systematic problems, and they have similar views as well as points of contention.
Better (not bigger) Vermont started in 2005 as “Vermonters for a Sustainable Population.” At that time, a group of residents came together concerned about the impact of the state’s growing population on the environment.
In 2018, the group changed its name and began advocating for a “steady state economy” which doesn’t expand beyond the state’s ecological limits.
Board president John Bossange said the group works to educate residents and government officials about the state’s finite natural resources.
“We can preserve enough of the environment that we can mitigate climate change, and we can help our family farmers keep their land, and we can keep other lands for people who want to farm on it to provide our own food,” he said.
Simultaneously, the group knows Vermont needs more affordable housing for low- and middle-income residents.
“The developers are building to meet the market,” Bossange said. “There are plenty of people who are out of state investors buying the $750,000 homes, and they're not building $400,000 homes where somebody like you and I could afford a mortgage.”
Better (not bigger) Vermont supports development in downtowns and village centers where there is already the necessary public infrastructure, like roadways, water and sewer.
Bossange pointed to new housing and commercial development on Market Street in South Burlington as an example.
“That's fine and that is kind of how dense housing works,” he said. “What happens when you build in open fields is that you have to build and maintain all the new infrastructure to get out there, and it’s very costly, and the towns can't absorb that and it shows up in our bills.”
Better (not bigger) believes developing more densely is not only more cost effective, but is better for the natural world. Town centers provide more opportunities for walking and biking, which have less environmental impact than cars.
“We need [to conserve the land] to make it sustainable, so we don't have to import all our food,” Bossange said. “If you don't build on natural areas and you build it more densely in other areas, you can save a lot of the natural environment.”
Vermont Futures Project, on the other hand, advocates for growing the state’s population, which has been relatively stagnant for the last 25 years.
If every town in the state recovered its lost population to levels it used to have, there would be 70,000 more people living in Vermont,.
Executive director Kevin Chu said increasing the population will keep the state from experiencing worker decline and would mean more funding for public infrastructure and social programs.
“Many of these communities probably put the roads in place for a bigger population,” he said. “They may have schools that are underutilized, that have fewer kids in them today. The infrastructure is now being supported by a smaller tax base because people have left…There are fewer people trying to support the same infrastructure that accommodated more people in the past, it needs more taxes per person to support them.”
Right now, Vermonters are facing scarcity, Chu added, but according to a recent Vermont Futures survey, many prefer abundance.
“[With scarcity,] we cut things, services, programs, consolidate and do fewer things which cost less money,” Chu said. “But there is this overwhelming sentiment [with the Vermonters surveyed] that actually they really like having things like schools and hospitals in their communities, and those are things that we should try to sustain, and we should try to sustain it affordably.”
When some people complain about the lack of housing or employees to fill jobs, Chu finds it helpful to ask questions and set goals, like how many people are needed to fill the workforce shortage or how many houses are needed.
For example, the Vermont Department of Labor estimates 17,150 retirements annually through 2032. To make up for that loss, Vermont Futures projects 21,700 new employees will be needed each year.
“When taking a look at sustaining a community, sometimes the word sustainability is thought of in a static sense, like how do we keep things exactly the same?” Chu said.
“In reality, things are changing all the time, rural communities have experienced significant change throughout Vermont's history, and a lot of that change has actually been depopulation. A lot of towns are getting smaller,” he added.
To get people to move and stay in Vermont, housing needs to be more affordable and abundant. Chu sees alignment with how Vermont Futures and Better (not bigger) approach development through the lens of building more densely.
“If you have more people using the same amount of infrastructure, then it's going to cost less per person in terms of assessing costs of either existing infrastructure or new development,” Chu said.
In terms of building more affordable housing in the shorter term, Vermont Futures prefers to focus on what fees and regulations the state can control, versus factors outside of the states control like federal interest rates, material costs and international markets.
“The cost of housing can feel overwhelming, but the way we make progress is by saying, ‘Okay, what are the components, and what do we have control over as a state, and can we make progress in changing some of those things to make it a little bit easier?’” Chu said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here