A year in review for the Colchester Police Department from community partners, plus policing policy updates

Posted

COLCHESTER — The selectboard approved an update to the Colchester Police Department’s authoritative directives, and heard from partners at the Essex Community Justice Center and the Howard Center at its meeting Tuesday. 

Update to Colchester Police Department’s General Order No. 1 

Acting Chief of Police Pete Hull alongside second senior officer Roger Fisher — who may fill in for Hull in the chain of command as needed — joined the selectboard to discuss the update to Colchester Police Department General Order No. 1. 

General Order No. 1 outlines employee requirements, organizational structure, a written directive system and authority of department personnel. 

The proposed changes in language were mainly made for clarity, Hull said. 

“Only general order 1 requires approval from the selectboard and is the foundation that provides a structure in the operation of the police department,” Hull said. “We have 49 general orders in total. It is important that we review them all and make updates on a regular basis whether it's because of a change of state law, new requirements or change in best practice.” 

The changes to the general order include the addition of a preface which formally establishes who CPD is as a town department, as well as to formalize access to personnel records for the town manager, assistant town manager and head of the human resources department. 

It also brings many directives previously existent within the order for sworn officers to explicitly include all non-sworn department members, such as dispatch and records employees as well as the evidence technician and the new support service manager position. 

“As we move as a department and as a profession towards a larger role for civilian staff, who will be filling responsibilities within the department that had been traditionally been done by sworn personnel, more accountability and integrity becomes that much more important,” Hull said. 

The only other real change, he said, was to add clarity around the use of department identification and its logo, for any non-traditional uniform shirts that may be used in training or at an event, which need approval so the department has control over who identifies with CPD. 

Selectboard member Maureen Dakin recommended adding explicit mention of the town employee handbook’s code of ethics, which applies to all town employees already — CPD included — so as to make even more clear a commitment of police in town to an ethical vision grounded in the local community. 

This would be in addition to the already-existing code, which is strongly influenced by the International Association of Chiefs of Police, and is a national standard. 

She also recommended removing a portion referring to town “laws,” as technically, towns make ordinances while federal and state governments make laws — among a few other notes, many of which were about sentence structure or typos. 

It was agreed that all Dakin’s recommendations be added to the draft for final approval, with the exception of the removal of the “law” language, as Town Manager Aaron Frank felt they should consult with the town attorney before doing so. 

Selectboard members collectively agreed to revisit the matter during the next revision period, which occurs annually, and otherwise, approved the updates to General Order No. 1. 

“Aside from the general order, we continue to work with our community partners to include Howard, which is represented by outreach [team lead] Hanna Toof, and the Essex CJC which is also represented by [director] Jill Evans,” Hull said. 

At this, both women joined Hull in conversation with the selectboard. 

Howard Center Community Outreach report 

Howard Center Outreach specialists collaborate with police and service providers to coordinate support for individuals with various needs, and the program assists businesses in downtown areas and helps service providers by accepting referrals for people with social service support needs. 

Outreach workers offer support and respond to unmet needs related to mental illness and substance use, clients can self-refer or be engaged by team members on streets or in neighborhoods or referrals can come from service providers, police, family, friends, merchants and concerned members of the community, according to the Howard Center website. 

Aaron Frank told the Sun the Colchester Police Department was among the organizations heavily involved in the creation and funding of the Howard Community Outreach program as a way to add to services offered by the Town to meet evolving needs. 

“Colchester Police Department was one of the founding members of the effort to bring social services to those of any age,” according to the town’s website. “Colchester, along with nine other Chittenden County communities have partnered with the Howard Center to provide social service professionals to offer services to those with a variety of unmet social service needs including substance use disorder, and mental health issues.” 

Individuals are self-referred to the Community Outreach Program or they are engaged by a Community Outreach team member. The program also receives referrals from service providers, police, other first responders, families/friends, merchants, and concerned community members. 

Team lead for the Howard Center’s community outreach program, Hannah Toof, opened her presentation to the selectboard with some information about her team’s current staff. 

Currently, Toof is one of a team of five people, though when they are fully-staffed they will have hired one more full time employee to join the outreach team, and are also a liaison for the First Call crisis hotline for Chittenden County. 

The current outreach staff collectively has about 20 combined years of experience at the Howard Center alone, with a wide variety of experiences in other fields as well, with the ability to provide behavioral interventions with children from a wide range of backgrounds, experience in responding to substance use related calls, and crisis de escalation. 

They also have access to clinical backup who can provide information, advice and support. 

A large portion of what they do is navigating the involuntary hospitalization process for people deemed a danger to themselves and others, which they partner largely with police on, to make sure it's safe for everyone involved. 

The outreach folks have a team line 802-488-7778 which can be accessed by anyone. 

In the past year for Colchester, the breakdown of people who call for their service included 40 self referrals 23 from First Call for Chittenden County. The largest portion was 166 from the police department, as well as 20 from parents or guardians. Fifteen were outreach initiated and then 35 would be miscellaneous such as a neighbor, a friend, merchant or business owner. 

For Colchester in fiscal year 23, there were 299 total calls to service, which is the third largest volume of calls for all nine towns the program serves. 

Contacts from Colchester to the Outreach Program accounted for 17% of the total contacts for the FY23 year, at 299. 

A majority of the service provision contacts from Colchester residents this past year were over the phone, with 187 services being provided via phone and 112 in-person, face-to-face visits. 

Colchester saw by far its highest rate of service from the Community Outreach Program in the first quarter of FY23, at 113, with a significant drop in the following quarter at 55. In quarters three and four, the program gradually increased services to the town, with 59 and 72 service provisions for each of the last two quarters respectively. 

The community outreach team makes a clinical note for every interaction, checking off boxes of demographics, the presenting concern, what service they provide and more. 

“We respond to a wide variety of needs,” Toof said. “It's not just mental health, which is often what people think Howard Center provides. So this list is not exhaustive, but it is the primary issue that we may have identified in each call.” 

Needs they respond to ranges from dangerous, disorganized behavior — like erratic driving or public nudity — domestic violence, mental health concerns, family conflict, responding to families in the home after school, helping parents manage difficult behaviors for their children, and management of grief and loss, especially for suicide postvention aid. 

They also do a lot of work with those experiencing homelessness and housing insecurity, connecting people to their medical providers and other service coordination. 

Anytime team members go out for proactive outreach in communities, they perform supportive listening, crisis de escalation, consultations for service coordination, followup or other forms of engagement.

“I walked Church Street [in Burlington] for eight years,” Toof said. “And part of what I loved about the job was being out in the community, seeing people starting to know who I am just based on me every day — and that is a mission I am bringing to community outreach.” 

Her team has been doing this with what they call foot patrols on Church Street and around the Winooski Circle and other areas where the public congregates, commonly in partnership with law enforcement, to publicly engage the community on the ground. 

Toof said she’d love to hear from Colchester for feedback about what foot patrol areas in town will be most helpful. 

The Howard Center has someone in the interviewing process to potentially fill the final spot on the outreach team currently. Once the position is filled, the team will be able to offer weekend coverage in addition to its weekday coverage. 

Toof herself is five weeks into her position as outreach coordinator, and in just one month has gathered 29 contacts in Colchester to assist with services. 

“It might not seem like a lot but that's one tenth essentially of what [the total number was] over a year,” she said of FY23. “So I'm hoping to see more volume of interactions in this community.” 

When asked how the organization addresses servicing communities that aren’t predominantly English-speaking, Roof said they’ve partnered in the past with community resources such as AALV in Burlington and other organizations that can assist with translation services. 

They also recently began making use of an interpreter app called LanguageLine, which is able to immediately get an interpreter present, either face to face or on the phone, Toof said. 

Anyone in need of substance, mental health or other social work assistance needs may reach the Community Outreach Program at 802-488-7778; the Howard Center main phone intake line at 802-488-6000; or the First Call for Chittenden County hotline at 802-488-7777. 

Essex Community Justice Center report 

Essex Community Justice Center’s mission is to create opportunities with the communities it serves for restorative approaches to crime and conflict that promote justice for those affected according to its website. 

Jill Evans, director of the Community Justice Center — which works with several municipalities including the Colchester Police Department — has been in her position for eight years. 

The center has a memorandum of understanding with the Colchester Police Department, informed by conversations with the State's Attorney's office, around what kinds of cases the state's attorney would support being referred directly to restorative justice panels at the Community Justice Center, instead of sending them to the court system and through the criminal legal process, by way of a pre-charge program. 

The panels are facilitated by trained community volunteers and serve as a proven and cost-effective means to address low level offenses. 

Through a series of conversations, the panel process holds those responsible for crime and accountable for their actions, providing an important opportunity for those affected by crime to share their stories and identify needs for repair. 

A vast majority of the cases that get referred to them are referred to them by law enforcement and those cases are diverted out of the criminal legal system. 

In an overarching look at this year as compared to last year’s police referrals, there’s been a decline in FY23 following a gradual upward trend towards more police referrals over time — the same trend is true of neighboring towns, Essex and Milton. 

“I'd be happy to have conversations,” she said, in reference to figuring out why referral rates dropped this past year. “It wasn't just in Colchester, we saw that happened in Essex as well.” 

The center has two staff people that do restorative justice panels and when it gets a case referred by the police department, it has one person work with the responsible party and another who does outreach to people that are impacted by the crime or the conflict that happened and so they each have somebody to work with and support them. 

“They each get met with individually, prior to anything happening to screen for appropriateness,” Evans said. “For one thing, the person who caused the harm, needs to accept responsibility for what they've done. They need to have some ability to take somebody else's perspective in terms of how the impact might have affected the person that they aren't directly and how the ripple effects go out.” 

Once they're well prepared for what the restorative justice panel is, they go through about an hour-long process where three to five trained community members from Colchester meet with the person who caused the harm and the person who was harmed — if those harmed are interested in being involved. 

“When a case is referred to the Community Justice Center, victims are supported and their voices are heard in a way that doesn't happen in the criminal legal system,” Evans said. “And they are given choice and choice is power.” 

“In Colchester last year, they worked with 37 referrals and of those 37 referrals, there were 29 community members who were affected by the crimes and 18 wanted to be involved in the process,” she added. “So that's actually a pretty high rate.” 

Being involved in the process can be just submitting a statement, getting updates or actually coming to the process, where there's a set of restorative questions that are asked. 

“When you go to the criminal legal system and it's like, ‘What happened to you, should we do that?’” she said. “When you go to the restorative process, the questions are, ‘What happened, who was harmed and what needs to take place for them to be made as right as possible, again, whose responsibility is it to do that?” 

The goal is to come up with an agreement that attempts to repair the harm the best that they can and they have a couple of months to get that work done. Sometimes staff at the CJC have to come back and check in with them to see if they're making progress and then when complete, they demonstrate how they completed that process. 

The Essex Community Justice Center received 23 direct referrals from Colchester in FY14, 28 in FY15, 18 in FY16, 40 in FY17, 51 in FY18, 43 in FY19, 53 in FY20, 55 in FY21, 54 in FY22 and 37 in FY23. 

Of the cases that closed in FY23, 29 of the 51 responsible parties in the program successfully completed a restorative justice panel. Returned cases were largely due to an inability to contact the responsible party and several did not take responsibility for the crime. 

The restorative justice panel successful completion rate for Colchester completed direct referrals was 65% in FY16, 78% in FY17, 90% in FY18, 96% in FY19, 93% in FY20, 89% in FY21, 86% in FY22, and 91% in FY23. 

Twenty-nine community members affected by the referred crimes in FY23 were contacted by CJC staff to discuss the referral and how they could be involved; 18 affected parties participated in the restorative justice panels involving their situation, either in person, through victim statements, by way of requesting updates, or through restitution requests. 

Colchester residents provided 180 hours of service through the facilitation of panels in the community and $1,195 in total restitution was resolved through the panel agreement process by those responsible for the crimes in FY23. 

Quarterly referrals from the CPD were as follows: 

  • January-March 2019: 10

  • April-June 2019: 14

  • July-Sept 2019: 12

  • October-December 2019: 9

  • January-March 2020: 19

  • April-June 2020: 13

  • October-December 2020: 27

  • January-March 2021: 7

  • April-June 2021: 8

  • July-Sept 2021: 16

  • October-December 2021: 6

  • Jan-March 2022: 19

  • April-June 2021: 8

  • July-Sept 2021: 16

  • October-December 2021: 6

  • January-March 2022: 19

  • April-June 2022: 13

  • July-September 2022: 8

  • Oct-Dec 2022: 9

  • January-March 2023: 12

  • April-June 2023: 8  

The Essex Community Justice Center also tracks how many hours of service community members from Colchester provide in doing this work and how much restitution they collect, and they use satisfaction surveys for everyone who's involved — volunteers, people who cause harm, people who are affected by it and the parents and guardians of youth who cause harm. 

They also track the age of the referrals they receive, the types of crimes which officers are referring to, as well as now racial identity data.

#csnltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here