A Vermonter’s guide to navigating holiday stress

Posted

NORTHWEST VERMONT — This time of year for many conjures up a cornucopia of fall harvest visions, brings forth cuddly, candle-lit cocoas and stews, and sparks a childlike sense of wonder as the thrill of twinkle lights, caroling and snowy magic draws all the more near. 

However, with lost foliage, brisker temperatures and fewer hours of daylight to soak up — among holiday pressures that can creep up — this time of year also has the potential to add stress and overwhelm to already-hectic lives. 

In an effort to prepare with our readers for the upcoming holiday season, we spoke to two area-experts about mental health and self-care while weathering a New England winter. 

Here is what we learned. 

All things come in cycles 

Amanda Tanner is a licensed clinical mental health counselor who works as a clinical supervisor at the Howard Center, working with a caseload of her own clients as well as supervising other clinicians for their own licensure. 

Tanner said following daylight savings time, she and her colleagues typically see an increase in seasonal symptoms like depression or heightened anxiety in kids and adults. 

University of Vermont Medical Center physician psychiatrist and academic associate professor Andrew Rosenfeld told O’Rourke Media Group seasonal affective disorder is a common issue impacting Vermonters this time of year — essentially a more intense version of the winter blues. 

Lower mood, lower energy, and sometimes depressive symptoms like trouble sleeping, loss of appetite, thoughts of not wanting to be alive and more can become elevated this time of year, especially among folks who struggle to participate in fun winter activities, he said. 

Sometimes, the challenge of getting out there is caused by physical abilities like impaired vision or needing a wheelchair, which get harder as it gets darker and colder. The challenge of getting outside in winter could also result from people’s cold tolerance. 

“When that happens, we tend to do less of the socializing, physical activity — things that are fundamental to our mental health and wellbeing,” Rosenfeld said. 

The need for depression diagnoses and treatment in the region generally has also climbed in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, Tanner said. 

Indeed, the Vermont Department of Health reports the number of Vermont adults reporting poor mental health has significantly increased over the course of the last decade, especially for certain demographics of individuals, such as younger adults, low-education and low-income adults, LGBTQ+ adults and adults with disabilities. 

Vermonters also report a higher rate of depressive disorder than U.S. adults do generally — 25% as opposed to a nationwide average of 19% — and six percent of Vermont adults have seriously considered suicide, with considerable disparities for the demographics listed above. 

“We live in a northern climate and have significant shifts in the amount of daylight that we're having and the ability to be outside comfortably,” Tanner said. “The trade-off is it makes New Englanders very resilient.” 

Still, the snow and low temperatures can be very isolating for many people with medical or mobility issues. Tanner’s advice is to get outside and into the sunshine as much as possible, even if just in the context of a short walk, and supplementing with indoor time beside a window. 

“The other category for many Americans is the big holiday season, which can mean mixed feelings,” Rosenfeld said. “For some people, it's joyful and more togetherness. For others, it's family divisiveness or loneliness if there aren't connections to be had. Because [the holidays] are such a public phenomenon, it’s easier for people to feel left out.” 

He recommends checking in with oneself about what feelings and needs are coming up personally, and what barriers are getting in the way of that. Remembering to set realistic expectations and boundaries, and making time for those you feel best around, is important. 

“There might be people who we really want to see and stay connected to, but with whom spending an hour or a day is better than spending three hours or three days,” Rosenfeld said. “We talk a lot about being loving and being kind, but what’s equally important actually is being able to receive kindness and love.” 

Not only are the seasons cyclical, but so are things like grief and loss of loved ones — navigating a first holiday gathering without a loved one at the dinner table has the potential to be very tender and painful, and we don’t always get to control how or when grief comes up in life. 

It’s important to make space for whatever ways grief is showing up and to be kind to oneself and to others who might be sharing in that grief, even if you’re grieving differently, Rosenfeld said. 

In addition to the cycles of life and the seasons, cultural cycles are at play too, Tanner said. 

“We're shifting in seasons and then additionally, in our shifting in political systems — we just went through an election and are approaching another year of new leadership, and that can be anxiety-provoking for many, and heightens some of the economic stressors,” she said. 

“One thing that anxiety demands is certainty,” Tanner added. “Theres a lot of uncertainty right now in our world and our culture and I think that has an impact from COVID as well, as it took our world that we at least had a semblance or an assumption that we knew what was going to happen and that things are in our control, and just kind of blew that out of the water.” 

Now, many folks are grappling with altered expectations around how they can engage socially, at work, with travel and more, and that can come with fears and anxieties as well. 

“Those shifts are taxing,” Tanner said. “If somebody has already had a predisposition genetically or because of trauma or because of first childhood experiences or other stressors, that shift puts them at an increased risk to experience depression or anxiety and other mental health issues.” 

But one of the most helpful ways to orient oneself through the ups and downs of this time of year is to do so, always, through the lens of grace and self-compassion — and to prioritize not only self care, but also connecting with others and extending grace to one’s community, too. 

The value of social connection 

“Social connection has a lot of power — and may be the most powerful thing — to support our well being,” Rosenfeld said. 

When life gets hard, it can be really helpful to talk to a therapist if you are able, as well as to connect with a trusted friend or family member, reach out to local community resources, or to tap into a religious organization where one has found solace, Tanner said. 

Setting intentions about how one wants to participate around a holiday dinner table is equally as important as being intentional about how one is engaging with social media and the news, Rosenfeld said. So long as one feels safe and seen, it may be best to unplug and be present. 

On the flip side of that, in navigating tense family situations, it’s helpful to be able to recognize when you need a moment to step away from a gathering to get a breath of air or recenter. 

Financial stress can also sometimes be heightened during the winter, with higher utility bills as heating becomes more important and expensive, snow tires being perhaps hard to afford, and covering holiday travel and traditional gifts for family another possible barrier to connection. 

“It’s a very real and pervasive problem,” Rosenfeld said. “I think realistic problem-solving is helpful. Like, ‘Okay, if this is my financial resources, how far can it take me? What can I do? What's the best I can do?’ And keeping in mind what’s most valued in making those decisions.” 

Self-compassion is of the utmost importance, knowing some things aren’t your fault and that you are doing your best will help you focus on useful patterns of thinking, he said. 

He recommends tele-communication like video chatting to anyone in need of an alternative way to visit with far-away family members, as well as engaging in community centers and affinity spaces as needed to commune with others when the traditional family model is not an option.  

Though social connection takes time and effort and isn’t always easy to come by, Rosenthal said there’s research indicating even making the most out of brief or casual connections with strangers in places like airports or coffee shops — learning one unintrusive thing about someone in passing and they learning one thing about you — has a massively positive impact on people’s overall health. 

Also of note is social identities and certain racial, ethnic, religious or other identity-based demographics can play a role in the holiday experience on a number of levels as well. 

Whether its grappling with the implications of Thanksgiving as an Indigenous person, being unable to visit family for holidays as a refugee, being surrounded by a Christmas-centric culture as a non-celebrator, being discriminated against by loved ones because of gender or sexual orientation, or some other experience, there are a lot of identity-based experiences and various forms of oppression that can be extremely stressful, particularly in navigating the holidays. 

One of the best-proven stabilization strategies for anyone, both Rosenthal and Tanner agreed, is to put yourself out there, fighting that urge to gravitate toward a solo-style wintertime hibernation. 

“It's another reason that it's really important to have collective ways that we're supporting each other as human beings,” Tanner said. “Connection is one of the most effective ways to address mental health challenges, and the nature of many of those diagnoses that we see is that they currently isolate you.” 

“Depression is one that gets heavy, keeps you at home and makes you believe that others don't want to be around you, makes you not want to be around others, and the more that it pulls you out of connection and into isolation, the more impact it has,” she added. “That’s where the risk increases.” 

Accessible regulation strategies 

In addition to getting as much sunlight and fresh air as possible, light and brisk exercise increases endorphins and can really help seasonal symptoms, Tanner said. Getting good sleep and eating well are also crucial to mental wellness, she said. 

“And you know, listening to your body,” she said. “It's okay to slow down a little bit, to take that time to reflect, give yourself grace and compassion. Find things that bring you joy, even when things outside are very dark, physically and emotionally.” 

Though family dynamic stressors are incredibly common, they are also incredibly unique. Generally, though, Tanner recommends focusing on what you can control and doing your best to let go of what you can’t, as well as making space for self-exploration, journaling and finding mindfulness practices that work for you. 

Rosenfeld is a proponent of a dialectical behavioral therapy strategy known as TIPP: a sensory-based approach to emotional regulation, involving changing one’s temperature by stepping outside into the cold or splashing cold water onto the face during a moment of anxiety, engaging in intense exercise to let off steam, doing paced breathing — which can be as simple as a minute breathing in for four counts and out for six — and progressive muscle relaxation. 

The strategy can be tailored to suit specific needs. For instance, taking a warm shower, having a cup of tea or cozying up in a blanket if you’re feeling down and deactivated, rather than reaching for the ice tray as one might do when feeling panicky or too revved up. 

“Sometimes, distress is in your thoughts, but sometimes that tenseness is in your body, as the holidays approach,” Rosenfeld said — and these feelings often arise from factors outside of our control. “It's a good opportunity to say, ‘What else?’ Drink a glass of water, go for a walk, find a funny YouTube video, if your mind is full of thoughts that are not useful.” 

Meditation and other mindfulness exercises can also be powerful recentering techniques. Anything that isn’t harmful and could shift a person out of that sticky place of rumination is great, Rosenfeld said. 

Though there is no magic-wand, one-size fits all solution to seasonal or holiday stress, Tanner advises anyone having challenges to discuss them with their doctor, and with a therapist if possible, as therapists can help their clients process what’s going on and build skills to cope. 

“It’s hard, but the payoff is New Englanders are very resilient,” Tanner said of wintertime. “It builds a distress tolerance, and an ability to manage stuff that is unique to New Englanders… What this challenge also brings us is an identity, and what it teaches us is understanding that the cycle of the seasons, including seasonal symptoms, can come and go.” 

“There is a cycle in all things,” she added. “But traditions and routines and rituals also give us such strength and comfort and those are all very important as well. Do your best to have solid routines that care for your body, that care for your mind and connect you with others.” 

Further resources 

Beyond the perspectives and tips outlined above, there are a number of other online and in-person resources out there, like therapy and medication for chronic mental health ailments, and for moments of acute or immediate need, crisis hotlines. 

Some of the crisis hotlines available include the national 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, which offers 24/7, free and confidential support to anyone in distress, providing prevention and crisis resources to callers, who can access support by dialing 988; as well as First Call for Chittenden County, a Howard Center 24/7 crisis support hotline available countywide in Chittenden, at 802-488-7777; and The Trevor Project, which offers a 24/7 crisis intervention and suicide prevention national hotline specifically for LGBTQ+ youth and young adults, at 866-488-7386. 

In addition to its hotline service, the 988 website happens to offer an interactive webpage with tidbits of advice tailored to a couple of specific holiday-stress related issues, available here. 

A fuller list of hotlines and warmlines available to Vermonters can be found here, and information about the Howard Center’s new Mental Health Urgent Care is viewable here. 

The Vermont Department of Health and the Vermont Department of Mental Health have also recently partnered with the Center for Health and Learning to put out a Holiday Mental Health Social Media Toolkit, intended to promote uplifting messaging around mental wellness, support and self-care during the holiday season, linked here for those interested in participating. 

The toolkit directs users to a number of subsequent resources, including the 988 holiday guide aforementioned, as well as to additional sources of ideas for coping with the winter blues, for dealing with grief or loss, for managing compassion fatigue and burnout, for checking in on loved ones, for LGBTQ+ youth support, for food assistance and for general self-care. 

From all of O’Rourke Media Group to you, we hope you have a very happy holiday season — and that you find the space to give yourself grace and kindness, even in life’s tougher moments.

#sanl

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here