COLCHESTER — Colchester School District works toward promoting and upholding values of diversity, equity and inclusion in many forms.
Administrators at CSD bolster DEI across the district through a variety of student leadership opportunities, district-wide policies, in tracking academic achievement with respect to demographic differences among the student body and more.
This school story is the fifth and final planned installment of the Sun’s DEI series, which also covered general town initiatives, record-keeping entities, the economy and housing sector and the police department.
The school district has a diversity, equity and inclusion coordinator named Jamila Vogel who has been with the district for about three years, and provides DEI trainings for teachers, support staff and administrators. She’s also done some family nights as well.
These trainings have focused around bias, microaggressions, hazing, harassment, bullying and what to do when someone witnesses such behavior, how to supportively lean in to ensure folks on staff are holding themselves and their students accountable with regard to inclusivity, respect and kindness.
There are also a number of employees across the district that have opted into additional workshops through outside organizations, such as a St. Michael's College DEI training called the Racial Equity and Educational Justice Graduate Certificate Program.
Some teachers and support staff in the district are eligible to receive CSD funding for tuition to take the equivalent of a three credit college class, which eligible teachers may choose to use for this upon request.
CSD social emotional coordinator, Jayme Gaudet, commonly collaborates with Vogel on internal DEI-based trainings for CSD staff, with the two of them this fall having orchestrated a joint training for food service and school bus drivers.
In terms of promoting these values in academic coursework from a curriculum perspective, CSD teaches what is listed as the Vermont Common Core education quality standards.
“I think one of the things that we are trying to train teachers in is being aware of conversations that students might have as they're accessing the curriculum to ensure that our classrooms are safe places for students to have conversations when they need to,” CSD Superintendent Amy Minor told the Sun.
Holidays are not acknowledged in announcements on the public address system, but the school works to educate its community members about various holidays to be aware of observed by students and families represented within the district, in order to accommodate them as best as possible.
“We added into our calendar this year three evenings where we are not having any after school practices or meetings to kind of expand times when families can be together if they are observing a specific holiday,” Minor said. “All schools in Chittenden County are doing that.”
“We do try to educate our employees around inclusive holidays and having an inclusive holiday calendar,” Minor added. “We do the same with our families and students through the district wide newsletter. And so employees will get an email prior to the month starting with any holidays that would be in that month for us to educate them.”
Also worth noting, from a facilities perspective, is that about eight years ago Colchester High School added a gender neutral locker room, which has private showers and lockers within it, as well as full restroom facilities with lockable doors.
“I think that has been really supportive from an athletic standpoint,” Minor said. “At Malletts Bay School, there were two multi stall bathrooms in the main lobby which have been removed and replaced by two individual gender neutral bathrooms that are both handicap accessible.”
Prior to that, those two multi-stall bathrooms were very small, with doors so narrow that they were not wheelchair-accessible at the time.
“So that was also a great transition,” Minor said.
Additionally, this past fall, the main hallway bathroom at CHS was renovated such that all of those restrooms will be gender neutral moving forward.
The diversity, equity and inclusion work in Colchester schools is focused on ensuring that all students have the opportunity to succeed in school regardless of any and all marginalized identities held, Minor told the Sun.
“A student’s success should not be predicted nor predetermined by socio-cultural context or lived experience,” she stated in an email.
Minor provided the Sun with district-level data as opposed to a breakdown by each school because when the cohort size is less than 10 in a specific school, it has the potential to be identifiable when then compared with that specific school’s disaggregated academic score data.
The categories used are defined and required by the Agency of Education for state reporting.
Racial demographics district-wide are such that 1,734 or 80.6% of students are white, 123 or 5.7% of students are Asian, 98 or 4.6% of students are Black or African American, 96 or 4.5% of students are two or more races, 82 or 3.8% of students are Hispanic or Latino, and categories pertaining to less than 1% of the student population include 12 American Indian or Alaska Native students, one Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander student and five unspecified.
As a district, CSD reviews academic and social-emotional learning data for planning purposes so staff can provide support for students and report out non-identifiable data. Given how small many racial identity groups are, the school uses a combined group for students of color to configure academic achievement and evaluate possible gaps when accounting for race.
According to these reports, 48% of students of color, a group including all non-white categories noted above, are meeting or exceeding academic achievement standards, while 50% of white students are meeting or exceeding standards for academic achievement.
A larger gap exists between students experiencing poverty and those who aren’t. Although school meals are now universally free, 38.6% of students qualify for free and reduced lunch regardless — the school’s best indicator of its students experiencing poverty.
By that measurement, 35% of students experiencing poverty are meeting or exceeding standards within the district, as compared to 59% of those not experiencing poverty.
Larger still is the achievement gap between students with disabilities and those without — based on eligibility for Individualized Education Plans — with 25% of students with disabilities meeting or exceeding academic achievement standards, as compared to 55% of their other peers who meet or exceed those standards.
Educators and administrators at each school actively plan reading, math and social-emotional learning support and intervention based on areas of need shown in the data. These supports are layered and range from supports that are available to any student during learning to more focused and supplemental supports targeted to individual student needs, according to an email from Minor.
Data helps them determine the layer of support each student needs as it demonstrates when individuals are making progress in academic and SEL learning settings and the same is true of an entire cohort.
“What this data does not inherently demonstrate is the intersectionality of student identities and how that complexity impacts student data and the overall support that we provide to students,” she stated.
The district has used elementary and secondary school emergency relief funds to add academic and social-emotional assessments, provide professional development and coaching on evidence-based instructional strategies in reading and math, and to purchase materials that support learning and equity as well as to add intervention specialists in reading, math and social-emotional learning — all of which support student learning needs, Minor stated.
The district currently has more multilingual learners and newcomers than they did last year, and the numbers are expected to continue to climb — with a current count of 96 multilingual learners and 31 of them being newcomers, with the latter grouping referring to those with no English comprehension skills at all or extremely limited proficiency.
Last year, the district had only eight newcomers, but next year they are expecting even more than they have now, as Colchester is one of three towns that has been identified as a region to receive a number of families from Afghanistan, through a state refugee resettlement program.
“That number going from six to eight to 31 — it's putting a strain on the staffing that we currently have for those 96 students,” Minor said. “So when I first became superintendent eight years ago, we had 1.5 ML teachers for the entire school district and slowly over time, with huge thanks to the school board and the taxpayers, we've increased the department from 1.5 to four.”
Given the continued enlarging influx of newcomers now and next year, the school is considering hiring more multilingual educators as it works to build its budget for fiscal year 2025.
The measure used for English acquisition is known as the WIDA Assessment.
“You can get a score of a one through a five, and so we're seeing more students enter as ones — as you go up through the WIDA scale, you need less support to access learning in the school day, based on your comprehension and ability to speak the language,” Minor told the Sun.
Easing newcomers’ transition also goes beyond English language acquisition alone.
“Many of them have never used any type of technology or had access to computers,” said Meghan Baule, communications director for CSD. “And of course, in this day and age, we do a lot of that especially at the high school level. Bus transportation, even meals in school — so much of it is kind of easing their transition into schooling in America in general.”
Other changes CSD is seeing in its data is in the number of students that are experiencing homelessness — those numbers, too, are increasing.
In 2021 the district had 35 students experiencing homelessness who lived in Colchester and attended Colchester schools, with that number this year having risen up to 65.
There are also 30 students who now live in Colchester under homeless status but attend school in a different town where they lost their previous housing arrangement, in an effort to avoid destabilizing their educational setting. In these kinds of situations, CSD covers transportation costs for students experiencing homelessness to attend school elsewhere.
The school board approved an equity policy for the district Sept. 5, 2023, the substance of which took into account feedback and guidance from students, families, employees and field experts.
The policy states that the school board holds itself and all district, school-site decision-makers and employees accountable for building a district-wide commitment to equity for all members of the CSD community, inclusive of race, gender, color, creed, national origin, marital status, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, ethnicity, caste, language and linguistic diversity, socioeconomic status, religion, housing status, non-citizenship or immigration status.
“What this policy did for us as a district is it formalized our commitment to ensure that every student, every family, every community member feels safe, valued and heard throughout our district,” Minor said. “We have been doing some significant equity work over the last seven years. And I feel like this is just the document that formalizes our commitment to having inclusive schools.”
The district will incorporate principles of equity within all of its policies, programs, operations, practices and resource allocations, according to the policy.
“We recognize that disparities in achievement, opportunity and well-being may impact students and families in our district,” the policy states. “A student’s success should not be predicted nor predetermined by socio-cultural context or lived experience. The district affirms that each student can thrive given authentic opportunities in a supportive, inclusive and equitable educational system.”
Per the equity policy, the district will strive to:
Provide a learning environment and educational opportunities for students and employees that are equitable, anti-racist, culturally responsive, anti-discriminatory and inclusive;
Respect and honor the diversity and lived experience of all individuals;
Create a nurturing school environment where individuals feel welcomed, accepted, respected, included and supported;
Increase the awareness of disparities and inequities that exist in the district to create and sustain a climate and culture that supports equitable practices;
Cultivate and sustain school communities that embrace a collective responsibility to address, eliminate, and prevent actions, decisions and outcomes that result from and perpetuate racism and discrimination;
Address the harm caused to individuals as a result of bias and inequity;
Hold themselves as individuals in the district-wide community, as well as one another, accountable to equity, inclusion and belonging in our schools.
To realize the commitment to equity within this policy and as outlined in by Vermont Education Quality Standards, the district will implement the following:
Provide engaging, inclusive, anti-racist, culturally responsive, anti-discriminatory curriculum, flexible instructional and assessment practices aligned with current best practices and informed by district, state, and federal data on academic achievement, social emotional learning, school culture and climate;
Systematically use district-wide and individual school-level data disaggregated by race, ethnicity, language, ability, gender, sexual orientation and socioeconomic background to inform District decision-making to mitigate barriers that perpetuate gaps;
Provide every student with equitable access to all educational resources that respect their individual and intersectional needs, identities, cultures, backgrounds, abilities and experiences;
Educational resources include but are not limited to: facilities, technology, high-quality instruction, curriculum, support, grading and assessment practices, food services, co-curricular activities and transportation;
Allocate financial resources, personnel, supports, and opportunities based on need so that all students have equitable opportunities to achieve, engage, and feel belonging in an inclusive and welcoming school environment;
Offer robust opportunities to critically engage students with themes of diversity, equity, and inclusion including a comprehensive historical and socially conscious understanding across all academic areas that include diverse perspectives and positive and affirming representation;
Engage student, employee, and community voices, particularly those historically underrepresented and most impacted by inequity, with opportunities for feedback and engagement to influence and advise district and school based action plans, policies and practices;
Identify and counteract biased practices and policies that perpetuate achievement disparities and opportunity gaps — with factors that perpetuate systemic inequities, institutional biases and discriminatory practices to be identified, intentionally interrupted and replaced with more equitable and just systems;
Provide opportunities and programming that prevent bias-based harm through direct instruction and school wide events that promote a culture that uplifts diversity, equity and inclusion;
Incorporate trauma-informed and restorative approaches to behavior management and repair of relational harm in order to achieve equity in our discipline practices and improve school culture and safety;
Address bias-based harm and discriminatory behavior with robust protocols that are in alignment with district, federal and state policy;
Provide ongoing and continuous professional development and accountability at all organizational levels to ensure all employees are able to engage in culturally responsive practices and consistently identify, interrupt and prevent bias-based harm, microaggressions and hate emphasizing impact;
Maintain and embed equity into district- and school-based strategic plans by identifying measurable outcomes to mitigate barriers that perpetuate achievement gaps and improve the culture and climate for all individuals across the district;
Schools will honor cultural, and religious traditions not acknowledged by CSD and regional calendars by providing reasonable accommodations including but not limited to space and time for individual students where religious tenet require observance during the school day and scheduling considerations with regard to major assignments, evening events and assessments;
The superintendent shall identify outcome indicators as necessary to monitor this policy and shall provide an annual status report to the school board.
Although there are no procedures to accompany this policy, Minor said the district community consistently works to ensure the standards set in this policy are achieved.
“As a district we have an action plan and every building has an action plan,” she said. “They will have goals every year tied to the equity action plan based on where their building is. And then every year we do kind of a report to the community. And in that report to the community, we would be sharing some of our work towards those specific equity goals.”
In the event of a bias incident involving discrimination, the response would follow the procedures under the overarching hazing, harassment and bullying policy and its accompanying procedures to follow up with disciplinary proceedings and complimentary accountability measures on any student matter. The Title IX policy and procedures would also be used in instances of sexual harassment and gender-based discrimination as well.
Last year, the school piloted something called the YouthTruth survey, which is a nationally normed survey allowing the school to ask a host of questions to hear directly from student voices and acquire feedback from those experiences on how the district is doing on DEI-related matters and campus climate.
The school hopes in the near future to expand it to not only students but also families. This data will be collected as an accountability measure for how the school is doing in upholding its equity policy moving forward, Minor said.
Additionally, the district works to build student-based leadership teams in DEI areas, with active student groups at both the middle and high school levels providing feedback to administrators and working on various initiatives to ensure the student body is represented and considered in building initiatives to support positive learning outcomes for all.
Also in the works is an initiative in which each building is developing its own educator-based diversity and equity committee, with teachers working directly with administrators to ensure each building is on track with their action plans in this area.
“I think one of the components that we are probably most proud of from last school year is we had students go into other classrooms and students did a student-directed training around microaggressions,” Minor said. “And students had adult help to build the lesson plan, students talked about their experiences.”
There was a group of high schoolers that did these microaggression lessons specifically for kids in grade five at Malletts Bay School, which Minor said was very well received and it provided students at the high school with the space to be leaders.
“That's a great opportunity for younger students to see older students being leaders and talking about behaviors that we don't want in schools,” Minor said. “I think that's a very important proactive step in our hazing, harassment and bullying prevention model.”
Each building has co-curricular clubs connected to that goal as well.
“We want to work with our student body and we are providing for students in these co-curricular clubs, opportunities to learn how to be leaders, and so we've been partnering with a group called Up for Learning,” Minor said. “They help us to facilitate those trainings for students who want to be leaders and help make change in our building in a really productive way.”
Colchester High School also has a YouMatter group which is really active, which is also working around understanding students’ needs in the school learning environment and giving input to admin on components that the school can do to make the school a more inclusive place.
Minor said that in reflecting on the impact of the Black Lives Matter movement, which gained significant momentum in 2020, she believes it inspired more adult outreach to students to ensure they were hearing directly from student voices to understand weaknesses and areas which could be targeted for improvement.
“Post George Floyd, I think that is something that all buildings are paying really close attention to is student voice and their feelings on their experience in the schools,” Minor said.
All employees get together for what's called opening convocation, which is the first meeting of the school year, and CSD has always had students speak and share their experiences as an educational moment for our employees at that event.
“That's something that we're committed to doing so that educators hear firsthand how important their role is in making an impact on the student experience in schools,” Minor said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here