‘A hard pill to swallow’: Colchester mitigates tax increases while staffing town and maintaining service provisions, within market suffering from inflation and nationwide worker shortage

Posted

Editor's note: This story was updated Sept. 28 at 10:54 a.m. to correct a numerical figure and to clarify that the Rec Center will not require additional taxpayer dollars.

COLCHESTER — The Colchester selectboard discussed its budget development approach for the near future in light of market constraints and potentially increasing future resource needs at its Sept. 26 meeting. 

Increased costs of labor and materials, a worker shortage and inflation have culminated to greatly increase operational costs of running the town, as well as posing issues to the goal of recruiting and retaining adequate levels of staffing to carry our necessitated service provision needs and to maintain infrastructure. 

As town management and selectboard members see it, to continue on they must ultimately choose to either cut back service offerings — which several selectboard members say are already slim — or, increase taxes — which other selectboard members say nobody wants.  

There are 10,394 fewer people working in Vermont than there were pre-COVID-19, said Renae Marshall, deputy town manager, at last night’s meeting. As of July 2023, there were 0.7 people per open position, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. 

Hence, employment participation in the labor force is currently a far more impactful factor than the unemployment rate is, considering how many people are available to participate as workers and are for whatever reason not doing so, Marshall said. 

The rate of inflation experienced in the past year increased significantly in materials, supplies and labor, as have the costs for wages, salaries and employer paid benefits. 

The employment cost index and producer price index — two inflationary metrics — have both increased by 4.4% in the northeast including both the public and the private sectors since 2022. 

“We’re going to continue to look for ways to offset some of the increased expenses with reduced costs in other areas,” Marshall said. 

One area to account for in which the fiscal year 25 budget can expect to see an increase is for fire department staffing costs. 

For example, in fiscal year 24 the town hired a fulltime firefighter that was unbudgeted, bringing the total number of full time staff members in the town fire department to six. In fiscal year 20 there were zero. 

In spite of efforts to boost staffing where the town identified increased needs, there are currently 12 open positions in the town, with a majority of those being in the police department. 

There are seven open positions in the police department, one for a public safety dispatcher, two for public works maintenance workers, one for a public works mechanic technician and one for a paramedic. 

“Again, with fewer people working or looking for work in Vermont compared to pre-COVID, we are finding that there’s more competition between the public and private sectors for employers to fill positions which impacts the resources needed to maintain the current level of service,” Marshall said. “The external pressures and constraints in Colchester means we have to balance these inflationary realities with an understanding of external pressures and constraints.” 

The town’s approach to evaluating service provisions and looking for efficiencies without reducing current offerings all while operating within the aforementioned fiscal realities is a complicated equation to find solutions for, but town management is working hard to keep tax rates as affordable as possible without reducing current levels of services. 

Last year’s budget increase was 8.3% and has averaged 4.6% over the past three years. 

Last year’s tax rate was 6.1% and has averaged 3.6% over the past three years. 

As suggested by selectboard member Tom Mulcahy and agreed upon by the collective members of the selectboard, town manager Aaron Frank along with Marshall will consider 8.3 a definitive target starting point as the goal for what the tax percentage increase in the upcoming year will be. 

“Any argument in the future to defend an increase or a decrease should be made from the point of this figure,” Mulcahy said. “Take a long look as to what you can reduce. I know we don’t like to do that but each one has something that can give that’s much less needed than the rest of the services we provide.” 

Despite strong advocacy for a tax increase equal to or less than that of the year prior from Mulcahy, this number is subject to change depending on future needs and feedback. 

Competing factors at play 

Arguments were also made to defend the prioritization of maintaining the current level of services over keeping taxation increases to a minimum. 

“What do we sacrifice for services?” asked selectboard chair Pam Loranger of the room. “I think it’s an exercise worth having, I just have the sense that we’re running pretty lean as it is, where else are we going to reduce costs?” 

Frank also pointed out that it isn’t crystal clear which service provisions are ‘more needed’ than others, as needs are subjective and vary from person to person. In other words, different people care about receiving different services, so non-core provisions can be hard to identify. 

With a lack of workers, the struggle to meet the town’s needs already feels dire enough in many departments. For example, the Planning and Zoning Department had eight people before the impacts of the worker shortage set in. Since then, staffing levels have halved. 

“We shifted some things back to the state, but I don’t see how we could run it with less than four,” Frank said, specifically in reference to transferring responsibility for on-site wastewater and commercial building inspections to the state. “Right now, it gets too backed up, those complaints come to Renae and I. We have to reprioritize.” 

Maureen Dakin encouraged town management to start addressing future resource awareness needs now, regardless of whether it’s going to increase the budget. 

“We don’t want to get into a critical situation in any of those resource awareness categories because then we’re just playing catch up,” she said. “We’re running pretty lean here.” 

“If we’re going to staff the town adequately and we’re using our employees toward the private sector, it’s inevitable that we’re going to have to start [raising] some of those wages,” she added. “If we fall too far behind, we’re not ever going to be competitive in such a tight labor market.” 

The public sector has always struggled to compete with the private sector for employees, as private venture capitalists and other private employers have the capability to offer more attractive payment and benefit packages, Frank and selectboard member Charlie Papillo said. 

However, with such a drastic lack of worker participation in today’s market, this competition has only become exacerbated, with the public sector consistently winding up with fewer resources and greater unfilled needs. 

“We’re seeing it all across the country where people are leaving the workforce and it’s hard to get people to come into work, and when you ask about cutting services, nobody wants to cut services,” Papillo said. “It’s a hard pill to swallow but when you ask somebody about reducing their taxes. The question to ask them directly is, ‘well what do you want us to cut?’” 

“As a community, I think we need to put more money into economic development and be very aggressive because that's what’s going to get you out of a hole is more tax base, people who live here,” he added. “We’ve got a Rec Center coming, which hopefully will bring people to the community, but we need houses for them to live in — we need to build more houses.” 

This is something Papillo hopes the economic development office will hone in on even more aggressively, though he does believe they’ve been doing a good job thus far. 

“Either you raise taxes, or you bring more people in and you spread it out,” Papillo said.  

Still, Dakin said the housing crisis isn’t something the town can fix on its own. 

“There’s so many things beyond our control,” she said. “But I really don’t want us to fall behind to complicate the issue more so.” 

Dakin believes the town needs to be more forward-thinking and play things out to avoid winding up in crises — which when they occur, ultimately receive all the attention and all the money. 

“I don’t want that to happen in Colchester when we have so much going for us,” she said. 

Despite employers in the private sector having the capability to reach in with significantly higher offers than what job listings advertise when necessary, contributing to their ability to outcompete public sector employers — as Frank noted — Loranger still pointed out evidence of hope. 

“We have employees that enjoy working here so much that even after retirement they came back and offered their services,” she said. 

There are people who have retired and have come back to continue to offer their services to the town, including in human resources, police, cemeteries and more, which Loranger sees as living proof of how rewarding it is to work for the town. 

Read on to learn more about the areas of awareness projected for potential near-future needs that Colchester taxpayers may have to fund over time. 

Possible future resource needs  

Colchester households grow by about one percentage each year, which leads to more required municipal services, Frank said, so to add needed service increases in a cost effective manner, the town has in the recent past reduced two positions in administration but increased staffing and public works, public safety and parks maintenance. 

In fiscal year 17, the town added a public safety dispatcher; in fiscal year 19, a rescue staff member, a police officer and a parks maintenance staff member; in fiscal year 21, a public safety dispatcher and four fire department staff members; and in fiscal year 23, one parks maintenance staff member. 

In fiscal year 24, the town added a new technician and an assistant fire chief, as well as a firefighter and then a shared public works and parks maintenance staff who worked on parks in the summertime spring fall and helped with snow removal in the winter. 

The possible future resource needs outlined below are not all going to come to fruition within the next year, but aim to serve as awareness areas for the selectboard and the public to be aware of potential needs that may spring up in the near future, Frank said. 

  • The Assessor’s Office will likely require increased personnel for a two-year period for a town-wide reappraisal to be completed in 2026. Through a reappraisal fund that’s been saved up, this shouldn’t involve a tax increase; however, taxpayers may have to take on the cost of all the work involved in a possible mandated 2032 reappraisal, due to recent state legislation that removes funding for local reappraisals. 

  • The town has invested significantly in the Fire Department, with the FY 24 budget at 48% or $487,775 higher than it was pre-merger, just over three years ago. Still, areas to watch include monitoring annual funding for needed air packs, radio and bunker gear replacements — all of which are budgeted for, up to a point. The town is currently applying for grants to fund somewhere between $150,000 - $450,000 worth of air packs to be replaced in batches. It ordered a $750,000 replacement for a 2007 pumper truck, which is expected for delivery in early 2024. The Fire Department is primarily staffed with about 60 volunteers, including Saint Michael’s College Fire deployment volunteers, alongside 6 full-time career members. Service is heavily dependent on volunteers and it’s important to attend to recruiting, training, encouraging and honoring them. 

  • Human Resources is stretched with just 1.25 full time employees to keep up with hiring and onboarding all employees. The town may need to consider adding resources to help review and update policies and to address local and nationwide trends of increased employee turnover rates, which results in a greater need for training and onboarding. 

  • The Burnham Memorial Library has seen increased use of the meeting house for programming and has subsequently seen an increased need for $10,000 more in additional facility cleaning services. The library is largely dependent on Friends of the Library fundraising which currently provides about 90% of the programming budget, which works fine for now. However, Frank warned that if that support were to disappear, the library would need some resources from the town to keep things up. 

  • Planning and Zoning sees customer service back up at peak times, such as for refinancing and closings and more, and may need more staff as a result. Also, the Planning and Zoning digital record storage and permitting system is functional, but is a decade old, and may require funding for additional support or a replacement program. 

  • Pricing for private sector services and equipment used for the highway, equipment maintenance and buildings divisions of the Department of Public Works are increasing at pretty high rates, Frank said, and are subject to inflation rates estimated at about $38,137 annual increases over the next five years. Also, given expansion of the transportation system, which includes paths, roads and other Public Works needs — not to mention regulatory requirements and aging infrastructure — future growth will likely require an additional highway maintenance worker which will cost about $80,000 including wages, employer-paid taxes and benefits over the next five years. 

  • The new Recreation Center has a budgeted non-tax program fee to fund part-time staff and contracted staff for fitness classes and programs. However, the Parks and Recreation Department may need additional unforeseen funding for maintaining seasonal park staff, which remains a challenge and becomes more difficult each summer, Frank said. The town did create a shared Public Works and Parks maintenance staff position last fiscal year, to work in parks over the summer and on winter plowing and general maintenance in the winter. Introducing more hybrid positions may be of use in solving the staffing issue in both departments moving forward. 

  • Rescue squad staff is composed of 39 volunteers, and at any given time two thirds of staff on the ambulance are volunteers. Without this, the town would have to pay five to seven more staff members at pretty significant costs annually, Frank said. As the service needs go up, there may also be a need for a second ambulance to run on certain shifts or portions of shifts, with operational costs associated. Should that happen, the second ambulance figure would come out to about $350,000 - $500,000 annually, plus $42,000 for a cardiac monitor and $10,000 for radios and miscellaneous associated equipment. 

  • Due to retirements and employees leaving the Colchester Police Department for other state and federal opportunities, there are seven unfilled positions out of 29 funded officer positions. The nine non-sworn positions are currently fully staffed and the town has added a civilian evidence technician which freed up one officer for other work. Human Resources has aided in recruitment efforts, but the department may need to adapt further civilian positions as in recent times, there are fewer qualified people interested in careers in law enforcement. Having foreseen a handful of retirements, the department has trained and prepared existing personnel to take on new positions, but staffing shortages still lead to high call volume per officer, which may necessitate an additional officer position in the future, in addition to filling those that are currently vacant.

#csnltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here