$115 million bond to appear on November ballot for future of Colchester’s schools

Posted

COLCHESTER — Colchester School District is putting forth a $115 million bond proposal, to complete what it says are essential, overdue facility improvements at all five schools. 

The bond initiative was detailed at Tuesday’s school board meeting, as well as at a school board meeting Aug. 20. The bond will appear on the ballot Nov. 5. The decision as to whether or not to give it the go-ahead is in the hands of Colchester voters. Here’s what you need to know. 

What needs would the bond address? 

The bond will address CSD’s highest-priority capital facility needs, with a focus on safety, mechanical and building infrastructure, and capacity improvements to learning spaces. 

To an outsider walking through most of the schools, they may look good on the surface, but the systems behind the scenes are essentially hanging on by a thread, according to Superintendent Amy Minor and Charles Rowse, maintenance director.  

One of the primary functions of the bond is to update aging infrastructure. Major mechanical systems in the buildings have outlived their useful life, and going unaddressed, drain funding in power overconsumption and maintenance in the long term — not to mention, aren’t always safe. 

The heating, ventilation and air conditioning systems in particular, in conjunction with failing insulation and poor window weatherization, is of particular importance in the district. 

Currently, students are expected to focus and educators are expected to teach in sometimes 85-plus degree heat, while old AC units — which occupy most classroom’s windows out of sheer necessity — struggle to filter in cool airflow sufficient to keep anyone comfortable. 

“Unfortunately, a lot of people think these are luxury. They are not. They're a necessity,” Rowse said of the air conditioners in an informational video about the bond. 

“Sometimes even myself, I'm like, do they really need that?” he said. “But then I walk in the room and it's 85 degrees in there… God, they need it. They definitely need it.” 

Unit ventilators with old valves have, in the recent past, caused further problems and been an added expense simply due to their faultyness and incompatibility with modern repair parts. An elementary school ventilator flooded the entire library as a result, damaging books. 

Not only are the current HVAC solutions dated and ineffective alongside the poor building weatherization, but they’re also not cost or energy efficient — in other words, relying on these dated system combinations is more expensive in the long-run. 

Electrical systems would also be rewired to support modern technologies now critical in education. Old iron plumbing which isn’t functionally compatible with modern-day aluminum heat exchangers, would be replaced too. 

The district also hopes to install automated sprinkler systems for the sake of student safety. 

Beyond the HVAC, electrical and plumbing work that is needed, the school board and administration are pushing for the district to improve equity and comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act — as children with mobility devices are currently unable to adequately navigate classroom spaces, utilize playground equipment or even use many of the bathroom facilities. 

The other need considered most pressing by those on the front lines are the modern-day safety features that account for the cultural shift the nation has seen with regard to mass shootings and threats of such attacks. 

Due to their age, Colchester’s schools have been grandfathered into not being legally required to have — for example — wide lines of sight out of its schools’ entrance ways to see potentially nefarious activity. 

But for the sake of Colchester’s youth, the goal is to become code-compliant anyway. 

“If the facilities we have can't meet the security and safety needs of our children, then I think every single person in the community would agree that that's a problem that needs to be addressed,” school board member Ben Yousey-Hindes said at Tuesday’s meeting. 

“And the truth of the matter is, in many of our school facilities, they were simply designed and built at a time when what we would consider sort of modern security and safety protocols simply did not exist,” he added. “Times have changed.” 

In particular, the architecture of the visitor screening area at the entry to Porters Point School is currently deep-set into the building, blocking the view of those outside up until the last moment, and needs to be reconfigured to maximize the safety of students and staff from outside threats. 

“This isn't a matter of just cosmetics,” Yousey-Hindes said. “Colchester is an amazing community, and it deserves schools that match the quality of the people who live here, the people who come here to raise a family, the people who hope their grandchildren will have that opportunity.” 

School board member Laurie Kigonya said at the previous school board meeting she sits on the board and backs the bond to give back to a community that gave much to her family. Her children, now graduated, benefited deeply from a strong public education in town, she said. 

Also within the bond is funding to increase the size of school parking lots and bus loops, in an effort to address the inefficient, traffic-packed arrival and dismissal times schools have been experiencing as a result of their current status. 

The project was also largely motivated by the fact that the preschool program is currently housed in the Malletts Bay School alongside a student population otherwise composed of upper elementary students — this bond would move pre-K in with lower elementary schools: Union Memorial School and PPS. 

This shift would eliminate one transition and allow for enhanced alignment and continuity of education, keeping the district’s youngest learners around similarly-aged peers to look up to and engage with. It also facilitates multi-year relationship building with building staff and educators. 

Behind the sense of urgency, and why this work matters 

Although there is a narrative that schools statewide are seeing declining enrollment — and although generally speaking, this tends to be true — the opposite is the case in Colchester. 

Many of the fixes that would be addressed by the bond, if approved, would aid the district in adequately keeping up with servicing student needs — needs which remain stable, and are even slowly growing, with future growth projected. 

Also included in the bond are several expansions which would increase space to accommodate current and projected enrollment counts. 

In the 2019-2020 academic year, the district had 2,144 students. Today, in 2024-2025, it’s working with 2,202 students. In 2029-2030, it’s projected to host 2,322 students. These figures exclude pre-K student counts. 

As it stands currently, students are using hallways, storage closets and tiny lobbies, simply to access their critical supplemental literacy, math and multi-language support services. 

“As the district has grown in terms of the number of students, as it's grown in terms of the complexity of needs of those students, we have really had to Frankenstein some spaces together, to put it mildly,” Yousey-Hindes said at the most recent school board meeting. 

The students with the greatest needs have the fewest spatial resources — so the renovation would include new classrooms in most district schools to ensure space can both keep up the general student population as well as the district’s most vulnerable learners. 

The expansion would, in conjunction, increase usable storage space to house needed educational materials and athletic equipment, and will also reallocate spaces that were previously available to adults and professionals in the building back to them — as many office and conference spaces have, by necessity, been transitioned into learning spaces with dividers. 

There are also insufficient spaces available for hosting large gatherings and community events. UMS functions with what they refer to as a “cafe-gymna-torium.” Time is wasted daily, setting-up and removing lunch tables. The bond would create separate space for each of these activities. 

The district's two K-2 schools, UMS and PPS — both built in the early 1950s without having seen any major renovations since the start of the 21st century — will undergo fairly identical renovations with bond approval, including two-story additions and a total overhaul of mechanical, electrical and plumbing systems. The two plans also include removal of the oldest sections of both buildings and adding bus loop and parking area expansions as aforementioned. 

The gym, core classrooms and art spaces have never been updated at Colchester Middle School — in fact, there has not been a single substantial renovation to CMS since it was constructed 56 years ago in 1968. In addition to mechanical systems updates, CMS would see expanded spaces with bond approval, as well as a more clear and organized entryway. 

“There are things that just feel too expensive to do today, and so you push them off until tomorrow, and you push them off until tomorrow, then maybe next week,” Yousey-Hindes said. 

“And in case of the district, there are certain major, major needs that we've said, not only maybe tomorrow or maybe next week, but maybe next year, maybe next decade, in some cases, with all due respect to Colchester middle school, maybe next generation — literally generation,” he added. 

MBS, which currently houses grades 3-5 and pre-K, if the bond is approved, will see the current pre-K space become much-needed support service space for upper-elementary students, as preschoolers are redesignated to PPS and UMS. 

Colchester High School will see minimal infusions of funds, as it has already received a community-supported bond to update its science labs in 2013, which was a project that came in under budget, with leftover funds used with community approval to renovate the Performing Arts Center in 2015. Last year, the district remodeled the CHS bathrooms. 

With the tentative approval of the new bond, UMS, PPS and CMS would see more major renovations and improvements as outlined above, with smaller projects being completed at MBS and CHS — namely a new roof and windows at CHS. 

Increasing need aside, experts say inflation is expected to level off and contractor availability to improve — hence the school board and administration’s position that the time to act is now. 

A look at the funding strategy 

Minor describes Colchester as a historically low-spending district — and on paper, it is indeed still one of the lowest-spending districts in Chittenden County. This fiscal year, Colchester’s spending per equalized pupil is second-lowest in the county. 

Colchester currently spends $12,818 per equalized pupil, as compared to the statewide average $13,292. Colchester spends less than Milton, Winooski, Mount Mansfield, Burlington, Essex Westford and Champlain Valley districts, in ascending order from lowest-to-highest spenders. Only South Burlington spends less than Colchester, and by a mere $34 per equalized pupil. 

Part of how CSD has kept spending relatively low is by piece-mealing projects together in the past to address only the most dire of needs each year, and only one project at a time. However, this piece-meal strategy of plugging holes only after they burst can’t keep up with the pace at which structures are failing, and could never address the fact that spatial needs are growing. 

All building principals presented at the meeting this week, and Principal Chris Antonicci of UMS  advocated for proactive, rather than reactive, facilities management. 

“Every summer, I am worried we're going to experience what North Country and Milton are experiencing right now,” he said. “That something catastrophic is going to happen, and we're going to be scrambling, and if COVID taught us nothing, [it’s the dangers of] trying to create remote learning while the kids are trying to learn, which was a complete disaster.” 

“I'm hopeful that we can be proactive and address these needs,” he added. 

Even with the $115 million in bonds, which is substantial and would bring district spending up, CSD would still manage to remain one of the lowest-spending districts in Chittenden County, said George Trieb, CSD’s business and operations manager. 

The cost of the projects have doubled or even tripled in cost since the need for each of these projects first arose — due to inflation, cost of materials and availability of contractors, he said. 

Waiting to approve separate, smaller bonds, or going back to piece-mealing this transformation, would only cost taxpayers even more in the long run. The subtle piece-mealing approach also allows for crucial maintenance and renovations to accumulate at a faster rate than they can be resolved — and the school board and district administrators believe a catch-up is long overdue. 

“Our educators are working through the facilities issues that we’re currently facing, and they’re doing a tremendous job,” Minor said in the informational video about the bond. 

“When you're in the buildings you might not know the challenges that we're facing,” she added. “But the challenges are real, and it’s time to invest for the long term: for our town, for our schools, and especially, for our students.” 

Project timeline and tax implications  

The effort that has gone into this bond proposal spans over a decade, and the final push has been delayed for several years already, to allow the community to recover from a pandemic and adjust to a post-COVID economy and culture. 

And board members recognize times are still tough for many, but given how much of this work has been deferred, the board’s consensus is this work can’t be further delayed. 

In 2013, the school board and district officials initiated the development of a comprehensive, long-term facilities plan, to address concerns related to aging school infrastructure. 

In 2014, the Universal Kindergarten Act went into law, ensuring children aged 3-5 have access to publicly funded kindergarten education, and expanding CSD’s need for lower-elementary facility space. 

In 2015, Colchester established an early education committee, with representatives from various community stakeholder groups, collectively tasked with researching the most effective  ways to meet the educational needs of pre-K through second grade students. 

Between 2016 and 2018, extensive research was conducted, including a traffic study, septic system analysis, demographic and enrollment forecasting and facility assessments. 

In 2020, the school board was preparing to place a bond measure for facility improvements on the ballot that November, but efforts were put on pause due to the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. 

In 2023, the school board resumed its facility planning efforts, focusing on creating a viable plan for the community to vote on. Each building principal dedicated time to evaluating and presenting facility needs and shortcomings to the school board last academic year. 

In early 2024, the district hosted a series of community engagement events involving students, parents, employees and community members to identify key priorities. School-based committees collaborated with architects to develop building plans and the board held multiple retreats to discuss the research and proposals. 

“We've been working on this project in so many different phases over the past 10 years,” school board chair Lindsey Cox told the Sun in a meeting last week. “And it's time to really trust that our community is ready and willing and excited to help us move it forward.” 

This summer and fall, the board finalized a proposal to present to the community. A timeline for sharing information with the public was developed in an effort to ensure voters have adequate time and information to make an informed decision come November. 

If approved, the bond will be repaid by tax dollars over 30 years, starting in fiscal year 2031, paying down the principal amount borrowed before interest, with interest decreasing each year as the principal amount of $115 million is paid off, in two $30-million waves and one $55-million. 

So for instance, bond repayment might start with approximately a $8.3 million payment in an early year, but by year 30, that figure will likely be close to around $2 million, Trieb told the Sun. Taxes probably won’t be impacted for about three years after bond approval. 

Each year’s payment would have to be approved in March within each year’s actual budget. There will be incremental hits for taxpayers, but not as drastic as, say, a 10-15% one-time spike, Trieb said. It would be more expensive in the long run, he reiterated, in a piece-meal approach. 

The physical work itself would be expected to be completed over a three or four year period, starting with the three primary benefactors: beginning at PPS in the first year, then moving on to UMS in the second, and then CMS in the third before doing finishing touches on CHS and MBS. 

The construction work will minimize disruptions via strategic phasing of renovations, adding new wings first and then moving students into newer wings to learn while aging wings are updated. 

The bond will expedite the duration of the work and any related disruption, and ultimately allow students to spread throughout new classrooms, using the space as intended — without creating the single-year tax spike that would be seen if this had all been wrapped into a singular budget. 

“We [usually] try to put some repair and maintenance money into the budget,” Trieb told the Sun. “But that total budget tends to be about a million dollars. You can see $115 million, it's a lot of work to be done. So it's just not possible to do that [as part of the typical budget cycle].” 

“Doing it that way is actually very expensive,” he added. “The longer we wait, the more it's going to cost. And some of these buildings just really can't go much longer.” 

It was decided based on community input to renovate existing schools rather than building new ones, in an effort to maintain some of the history and community charm of the lower elementary neighborhood schools. This approach is also far more cost-efficient than starting fresh would be. 

PCB testing has already been done on MBS and it has been deemed safe. CMS has been inventoried and is slated to be next, but there is no state funding available for further testing or remediation efforts, so Trieb said he expects the state testing will be put on hold. However, he said PCB and asbestos testing would be something the district would do as part of a renovation. 

Resident concerns and additional information 

At the end of Tuesday night’s school board meeting, Colchester resident and Vermont House candidate Doug Bishop asked the board if there is any potential way to make use of Colchester’s local option tax in future years to help pay down some of the bond debt. He also requested the district update an FAQ webpage to outline how taxpayers owning homes of different values will be impacted differently if the bond goes through. 

Resident Ralph Perkins, also in attendance at the meeting, asked if there might be any way to access federal or state assistance as part of the bond repayment plan, as well as whether there are any liabilities in making use of existing buildings rather than creating all-new ones. 

Bishop extended gratitude to the school board and administration for their hard work in coming up with the facilities plan, as well as for supporting his own son through the district 20 years ago. Perkins expressed stalwart support for the entirety of the project proposed. 

The school board and administration encourage folks to come to the polls informed and prepared to make a decision at the ballot box Nov. 5, or before then during the early voting period. 

To keep folks up-to-date in the meantime, the school is sending out informational mailings to residents and inviting the Colchester community to building tours and community presentations. 

Stay tuned on the Sun site for further coverage to come in relation to this bond proposal. 

In addition to this article, find a fairly comprehensive explanation of the bond and its purpose on csdbond.org. The site will be updated with FAQs and building tour dates as they become available. At that link, readers will also find a CSD YouTube video entitled “Our Town, Our Schools, Our Future,” for an opportunity to hear from CSD community members firsthand. 

Also available on that webpage are before-and-after overhead floor plans and building layouts for PPS, UMS and CMS, plus three-dimensional, full-color renderings of building exteriors as they’re projected to look in the end if the bond is approved. 

The site also offers more details directly from the CSD team about rationale behind proposed safety and security features, addressing aging infrastructure, optimizing learning spaces, honoring community values and the general impact of the bond for those interested.  

Questions about the bond and related renovations can be directed to info@csdbond.org — or if interested in potential further Sun coverage with yet-to-be-explored questions in mind, feel free to email suggested lines of inquiry for future reporting to eruehsen@orourkemediagroup.com.

#csnltop, #csd bond proposal

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here